Archives About Staff BagNews is dedicated to visual politics, media literacy and the analysis of news images.
October 21, 2013

Visual Evidence Way Back in 2010 of GOP Leadership Bringing Tea Partiers into the Fold

Mark Peterson mccarthy

Lest I leave you with the impression Mark Peterson has a one dimensional view of the Tea Party (his portraits of Cruz, Palin and Paul raising some hackles here last week), that was not his first documentation of the movement.

Roll back the clock 27 months to a slightly more ambiguous moment. It was July, 2011, after the Republicans took back the House with a tide of new Tea Party members. That July, the New York Times Magazine published a more-than-5000-word article on GOP House whip, Kevin McCarthy, and how the good-natured Congressman from Bakersfield had the chops to bring the renegades under control. If this paragraph alludes to the difficulty of controlling this faction, it’s certainly betting on the Whip — and a sense of  substance and reason:

In the end, there’s only so much control House leaders can exert over a congressman who answers to voters back home. Whips tend to recognize this and, at least in recent years, have relied more on cajoling than threats. McCarthy, who is 46, represents the affable extreme of this philosophy. In his sunny view, “A conference united around policies creates better legislation than using intimidation.”

In Mark Peterson’s photo that led that NY Mag article, we see (left to right, starting in the left foreground) Steve Womack, Sean Duffy, Michael Grimm, Nan Hayworth, Martha Roby and then, beaming in the light, McCarthy. Fast forward to now, can anyone say that McCarthy’s open door policy and cajoling talent has led to the mavericks climbing under his wing? (Well, certainly not Duffy, the Congressman, far left, who looks as loose and expressive as McCarthy. Duffy, who was a much less pious character when he starred in The Real World, recently attacked Ted Cruz on the shutdown for not going far enough.)

Looking at the figures in the photo and how they voted on the final shutdown bill that eliminated the threat and put the government back in business, that tally stands:

Steve Womack – NO
Sean Duffy – NO
Michael Grimm – NO
Nan Hayworth – (not re-elected in 2012)
Martha Roby – NO

Maybe his strategy to tame these activists has been to keep letting out rope. Even Kevin McCarthy voted “No.”

Correction 3pm PST (and more to the point): Poor Kevin voted “yes.”

(photo: Mark Peterson for The New York Times caption: The office of the House majority whip. From left: Steve Womack (foreground), Sean Duffy, Michael Grimm, Nan Hayworth, Martha Roby and Kevin McCarthy.)

  • LanceThruster

    “Will no one rid us of these meddlesome baggers?

  • tbc_RobertPrice

    McCarthy voted yes, but point taken.

    • Michael Shaw

      Thanks, read the wrong column. And even more fitting.

  • aSouthernMan

    Visual Evidence Way Back in 2012 of Dem Leadership Bringing Russia into their Fold
    Yes, a grand and fitting moment at the 2012 Democratic Convention, where
    they proudly stood waving to their anarchist party underneath the 2-story
    backdrop of Turkish Air Force jets flying over a Russian flotilla of Battleships
    to show their patriotism for US Veterans.
    Like their Legislation, their talk is dishonest, their facade is pictures, and their
    smiles are false – but their PR is great at fooling everyone. Even the introspective Bagnews experts, who look for the hidden meanings in photos mostly designed
    to disrespect and discredit any/all who fail to agree with the Anarchist views being
    forced on US by the Democrats.

    And now you have Obamacare – the namesake of the Democratic Party.
    And you STILL don’t see how illogical it is now, how stupidly it was created,
    destructively BAD it will be in the future as 1/6 of our economy is changed

  • gesind17

    find out how to make 35 bucks every day from your own home!! simply go to surveymoneymaker dot net

Refresh Archives

Random Notes