Archives About Staff BagNews is dedicated to visual politics, media literacy and the analysis of news images.
August 8, 2012

The Gabby Giffords Shooter Then and Now: Argument for Community Mental Health in One Glance

23df6bd7beb175041989b21ed9bc5ea3

“He’s a different person in his appearance and his affect than the first time I laid eyes on him,” said Judge Larry A. Burns, who then accepted the plea agreement and added that he found it to be in the best interest of everyone involved. — from: Jared Lee Loughner pleads guilty to going on deadly shooting rampage, killing 6, wounding 13 (WAPO)

Sure, we’re comparing a drawing of Jared Loughner to a photo. Still, the apparent lucidity (along with the reports of his return to competency) in the link above suggests what a good course of antipsychotics can do. (Wait and see, by the way, what kind of transformation similar treatment produces in James Holmes, the self-proclaimed Joker and florid psychotic whose decompensation led to the killing of all those people at the Batman premier in Aurora.)

Loughner New York Post cover

I know it’s easy to ignore the demands and requirements of community mental health, then just chalk up these rampages to evil when one of these damaged, long suffering and slowly decompensating guys finally goes off. The demons aren’t existential, however (regardless of what The Post caption says), they’re psychological … and often diagnosable and treatable.

What if our society put some investment in that?

(photo 1: Maggie Keane/Reuters. caption: Jared Loughner (C) is shown in a courtroom sketch sitting with his attorney Judy Clark (L) during his hearing in federal court in Tucson, Arizona, August 7, 2012. Loughner pleaded guilty to killing six people and wounding 13 others, including then-U.S. congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords, in an Arizona shooting rampage last year, and will be spared the death penalty in exchange. photo 2: AP)

  • Ra

    The drawing is quite a humane revelation. Loughner almost seems like a BEFORE and AFTER shot of a meth addict, an alcoholic, or another suffering individual in therapy. The artist presents Loughner as a being that is as engaged in his fate as his lawyer in the foreground (however, the blur of the man in the background makes him seem rather disengaged, as disengaged as some of the people who knew Loughner needed help but looked the other way). Interesting post.

  • jonst

    Michael, you asked:

    “What if our society put some investment in that?” I would argue it depends on what you mean by the term “investment”. Ok, let me say I suspect I can guess what you mean, and if I am correct, I wholeheartedly support where you going with it.

    But in the US…when a pol speaks of “investment”, given neoliberalism domination of our culture, they mean….can we do this and return a profit? Can we outsource it? “Pol” in this case means both Dems and GOP, first and foremost Obama, mister Hamilton Project Man.  As to Romney? Enough said by his name.

    So, “”investment” creates its own issues.

      

  • http://twitter.com/marcsobel marcsobel

    I’d go with “Guns don’t kill people, Lack of mental health care kills other people.”

  • Sirius_TheStarDog

    Another glorious chapter in the legacy of Ronaldus Maximus.
    Another blow-back from the reactionary zeal to drown the welfare state in a bathtub.
    Another abdication of societal interests to those of business.

    Guns don’t kill people.
    Bullets do.

Refresh Archives

Random Notes