Archives About Staff BagNews is dedicated to visual politics, media literacy and the analysis of news images.
August 19, 2012

Ryan/Romney One Week Out: Anchors A Weigh

Yes, I’m back. Long time readers know that every August, I slip off the grid just north of Watsonville (remember bootlegging the signal that year from the fire station?) and also do some camping in Yosemite. This year, we burrowed in to Yosemite Creek at about 8,000 feet. In the meantime, it looks like there was a little political news. (Full disclosure: I did see the USS Wisconsin shot last Saturday on my way up the 101.)

I’m sure plenty of key strokes were spent taking the two non-veterans to task for the Norfolk backdrop. What’s important to emphasize, however, is how much the disturbingly random USS Wisconsin setting (Virginia a swing state + Ryan from Wisconsin. Shwing!  …Or, was it McCain nostalgia?) only amplifies Romney’s lack of identity and, consequently, how at-loose-ends this campaign is for coherent, consistent and substantive  themes and symbolism.

What I really love, though, is the clever version at the top of this post photographed by Jason Reed of Reuters. (I should emphasize that the “straighter” and more widely circulated version of the view was this one.  I don’t know why CNN can’t be bothered with photo credits but I think it was distributed by Reuters by way of the Landov agency.)

Lined up as they are between the two facing flags, Reed drives home the silliness of the military setting by turning the boys into a “patriotism sandwich.” At the same time, Reed brilliantly orients senior and junior as close as possible to those turrets. I don’t know how consciously the Romney people thought about it, but I imagine the guns were meant to convey an aura of power and, more particularly, the sense of the Romney candidacy as now a double-barrel threat. Given the absence of military experience and the fact that Romney and Ryan are far prettier than they are foreboding, however, the photo is hilarious, the phallic nature of the image setting up a potency that the team not only can’t match, but isn’t even about.

The most substantive messaging fail here, however, is that Romney and the GOP, in sublimating the wives and the families in favor of flag waving and the instinct to go to war with just about anything, not only punt on their economic message, but seem to almost thumb their noses at the women’s vote.

Ryan behind Romney

Looking forward, I wanted to mention two more photos from the past week which caught my eye, both having to do with the Ryan choice, Romney’s M.O. and the ghost of Palin/McCain. This first shot, from the AP, drives home how much Romney needed a charismatic pick to juice his campaign. As much as Romney was willing and able to take such a risk, Ryan physically as well as ideologically fit the bill. The problem, however, is that Romney is not one to sublimate himself (or, in this case, “cede the focus”) to anyone and, as such, has bought himself one huge personal conflict.

McCain Palin CBS interview

Romney Ryan CBS

Although Ryan is far from the airhead and show pony Palin was, McCain’s cringing in their joint interviews thoroughly justified, I was struck by the similarities here. In this case, though, the dynamics have to do with how much a historically singular and dominating CEO has much patience for sharing the stage with any V.P.

(photo 1: Jason Reed/Reuters caption: Wisconsin Congressman Paul Ryan, left, stands with Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney after being introduced as Romney’s vice-presidential running mate during a campaign event at the battleship U.S.S. Wisconsin in Norfolk, Va., on Aug. 11, 2012. photo 2: Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP via couriermail caption: Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney, right, with his newly announced vice presidential running mate Paul Ryan during a campaign rally in Manassas, Virginia. photo 3: Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP via couriermail caption: Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney, right, with his newly announced vice presidential running mate Paul Ryan during a campaign rally in Manassas, Virginia. Romney/Ryan screenshot: CBS. McCain/Palin screenshot: CBS News with Katie Couric. February 11, 2009.)

  • Cactus

    When I saw a bit of the roll-out of Ryan, I too thought of the
    chutzpah of two war hawks who’ve never served (one of whom went all the way to
    France to avoid service, poor baby) daring to use a battleship for a backdrop.
    One does want to recall the infamous image of one former prez standing in front
    of banners on another battleship off San Diego. Not only do these folks have no
    sense of irony, they don’t know much history, apparently. But I just don’t
    think the phallic symbols are all that apparent in that photo. Other than the
    whole battleship thing being pretty macho. The turrets are at rest, limp, one
    might say; and they are aimed to the side and up, obviously
    inactive.

    However, I do see in both the photo of McCain/Pallin and the
    similar Romney/Ryan something else. A certain leer that is very suggestive: ‘I
    know I can’t, but damn your cute!’ Same look in McCain and Romney. Good thing
    he’s wearing that magic underwear.

  • BF

    Makes me think of Travolta in Saturday Night Fever

  • Impressed

    Is if possible Romney and Ryan are wearing matching shirts?

Refresh Archives

Random Notes