Archives About Staff BagNews is dedicated to visual politics, media literacy and the analysis of news images.
May 7, 2012

Campaign 12 Optics: Stadium Wars

Turn (ab)out is fair play?

Striking back at the media embarrassment Team Mitt experienced in Detroit back in February, posted this photo of Obama’s appearance at Ohio State with the caption: “OBAMA LAUNCHES CAMPAIGN IN EMPTY ARENA.” The photo was posted to Twitter by a Romney campaign spokesman. A few takes:

• The problem, right off, is that it’s a smaller space (20k) and less empty (14k) then Detroit. (Side note: Since when would Breitbart himself offer up numbers that undermined his own argument?)

• You really want to start a running meme with Obama comparing crowd size?

• A lame attack only makes you look lame. Unless you’ve got something really good, leave the swiftboating to Rove and the rest of the surrogates.

• Isn’t it a little early in the campaign for “mine’s bigger than yours”?

• You can’t fill ‘em all.

• Maybe it’s fair to ask, however, if the Detroit stadium photos would have drawn the same scrutiny if it was Obama’s event and not Romney’s. My take at the time was that the photos made news because they reflected concern in the air about Mitt’s lack of substance. At the same time, I do think the camera likes Obama better. Not that it’s based on any conservative or liberal bias, however. The media is much more “bandwagon” than that. Obama is just a lot more likable (which does effect the job).

(photo: Ryan Williams/Romney Campaign via Twitter)

  • Hugh Nohoo

    A shot from the back end of the arena showing lots of people sitting in the stands is the same as an “empty hall?”  Funny how the right wing propagandist did not take a shot from his vantage point towards the stage.

  • Scarabus

    Breitbart is dead, but zombies on. Who’s the person responsible? Was this person responsible right along? Anyone know?

  • Catherine McCallum

    That’s not an empty arena. It’s like they can’t stop themselves: Who’re you going to believe, me or your lying eyes? What a bunch of losers.

  • Molly

    I read elsewhere (on the internet, so it’s true ;-) ) that this pic was taken before Obama had shown up. I went to see Obama in ‘08 at a park in Leesburg VA and got there 6 hours ahead of time. The park is pretty large and by the time Obama took the stage we were packed in so tight we couldn’t move. However, an hour or so ahead of that we could sit down.

    This attempt at false equivalency simply illustrates how desperate the right is.

    • Michael Shaw

      Interesting. I didn’t even thing about “the when.” Might not be relevant but makes me wonder exactly what time the tweet was posted.

Refresh Archives

Random Notes