BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement

February 16, 2012

Campaign Video: Romney Fakes Drive Through “Inner” Detroit

Romney Growing Up video 3

Snapz Pro XScreenSnapz067

Romney Growing Up video 8

My Michigan, huh? It seems that Romney, no matter how hard he tries to present himself as a man of the people, keeps telegraphing how much he’s an elitist.

This new Romney web ad, “Growing Up,” involves Mitt taking us for a spin in the Motor City, establishing his roots there through his memories and his identification with the automobile and the auto industry … his Dad being the car company CEO, and all. (Do note, though, as much as he romanticizes the image of Detroit, he’s careful to always parse out he’s from “Michigan.”)

Romney Growing Up video 5

After driving us through a more suburban-looking neighborhood, knowingly peering out the window at “his Michigan,” watch what happens, though. Passing through a more urban and grittier set of houses, Romney decries the Obama Administration, it’s liberal policies, the mortgage crisis and the city’s hard times. Now, if you weren’t paying really close attention, the logic and flow of the tour would leave you thinking you saw these houses from Mitt’s car window. Breaking it down, however, you can see that the campaign inserted a video clip of the “more hurting” streets — Mitt never having driven there at all.

But then, maybe the point about elitism is the least of it. Some might say, instead, that the two sets of houses, with the image of the more inner-city looking “bad streets” and Romney bringing up liberals and Obama right then might actually code more for race.

Romney Growing Up video 10

Romney “Growing Up” video

UPDATE: Guess the wheels are falling off. DKos post shows that photo with Dad, supposedly in Detroit, actually taken at NY World’s Fair … and, that Chrysler he’s driving was made in Canada.

  • bks

    Is there a dog on the roof of the car?

        –bks

    • Karen H

      I read yesterday that Romney’s sons admitted the dog ran away after the family reached their destination in Canada. Sought asylum, I’m guessing.

      I wish I could find the link I ran across yesterday that identified the car in this ad as a Canadian import….

  • jonst

    I saw this ad and I immediately thought of the opening scene in the movie The Virgin Suicides…it opens with a scene of a Detroit suburb as the narrator expresses a pending sense of ‘trouble’ coming to the neighbor. Both economic trouble, and some deadly disease killing a lot of the trees in the neighborhood. Circa 1975.

  • James McBroom

    Uh, Mitt Romney’s commitment to our great state might be a lot more convincing if he had rescued his childhood home, which was torn down by the city (with federal money, most likely) after sitting abandoned. If I had a quarter of a billion, I would definitely drop a few thousand on my childhood house.

  • Ralfast

    Of course, no mention is made of White Flight or how the city sold Poletown to the car companies only to have the same companies then relocate to Mexico or how the more affluent communities past 8 Mile suck the life out of Detroit while keeping their own local tax brackets low.

    For a look on how suburbs destroyed the cities, just look up Mount Luarel decisions of the NJ Supreme Court, especially their findings on taxes, zoning and exploitation of nearby cities. 

  • Enoch Root

    The linked youtube video has been swapped out for a Florida campaign video. Oops. See the ‘growing up’ video here: http://www.usatoday.com/video/mitt-romney–growing-up/1452859778001

    “Michigan’s /edit/ been my /edit/ home, and this /edit/ is personal…” Nothing like sincerity, Mr. Willard.

  • Anonymous

    Does Romney really connect with anyone?  He won Florida so easily that I’m tempted to speculate that he does especially well with old people.  But he never reaches me at all.  I don’t see his appeal.
     
    Maybe he could turn things around if he levelled with people.  He could be up front about not coming from the same America as the rest of us – his Dad was CEO of a major corporation, fergoshsakes!  Somebody should tell him that this ‘jes folks’ act is unconvincing and off-putting.
     
    I’d like to see him speak candidly about economic privilege in this country.  That would show genuine leadership.  Instead he’d have you believe he got where he is on his work ethic alone, and that his social position as a young man had nothing to do with putting opportunities within his reach.  I also wish he’d address that Mormon thing, too.  In pretending it’s not there, he’s asking us to pay no heed to the man behind the green curtain. 

  • http://www.efn.org/~hkrieger Hkrieger
    • Ralfast

      Thank you for the link. 

  • LanceThruster

    The Mitt-wit really chafes my hide for some reason.

  • LanceThruster

    The Mitt-wit really chafes my hide for some reason.