BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, February 23, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



January 26, 2012

Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle?

NewImage

That’s quite an interesting use of a slogan here.

I can’t remember ever seeing a “Nixon’s Shifty,” “Carter is Soft” or “George H. W. Bush is Out of Touch” sign behind a candidate. And the “ISN’T WORKING” — do you think that’s an attempted dog whistle? Isn’t working… food stamp president…. are they saying he’s a lazy n-word? Seems they may be stringing that stuff together with an ulterior motive.

One other point: Many Americans are out of work and have been for some time. Maybe these citizens have given up looking in this climate. Still, it’s a minority of people who are jobless. “Bob isn’t working” is a remark you make when you blame Bob for his situation. His unemployment becomes partly if not mostly his fault. It’s a little dig his mother-in-law takes at him whenever asked. Her response isn’t, “Bob can’t find a job,” or “Bob works in a field that has been hard hit by the recession.”

Tons of conservatives say it every day about their son-in-law, their neighbor, the mildly disliked spouse of a cousin. It’s a subtle dig someone takes to say “the situation is Bob’s fault.”

Finally, isn’t the slogan just a little bit hypocritical coming from a guy whose been bragging about being unemployed?

– Karen Hull

(photo: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images caption: Republican presidential candidate and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney delivers a speech at the National Gypsum Company January 24, 2012 in Tampa, Florida. Romney’s speech was billed as a “prebuttal” to tonight’s State of the Union speech by President Barack Obama.)

  • LanceThruster

    Is there a line missing from the poster that makes it actually say:
    TRYING TO BEAT UP ON
    OBAMA ISN’T WORKING
    ??

  • http://abetterdogkennel.net/wordpress/2012/01/breaking-brad-thursday-jan-26-omaha-world-herald/ Breaking Brad: Thursday, Jan. 26 – Omaha World-Herald « Abetterdogkennel.net

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • Jonathan Hess

    It looks like an attempt to make an acronym that resembles OWS. Interesting.

  • Glenn

    “Mr. Speaker, I’m not anti-immigrant, my father was born in Mexico,” Romney declared.Tonight in the debates.

    If his father was born in Mexico, how could George Romney have run for President?

  • http://profiles.google.com/thomasgokey Thomas Gokey

    He’s stealing the line from Thacher’s campaign “Labour Isn’t Working” which was much MUCH more clever of a slogan. And how many American’s are going to get the reference?

    It takes a bit of chutzpah for Romney, the unemployed guy who pulls in over $57,000 a day, to claim that Omama isn’t working. Romney is the poster child for wealth without work.

  • http://abetterdogkennel.net/wordpress/2012/01/nc-govs-re-election-decision-could-benefit-obama-new-bern-sun-journal/ NC gov’s re-election decision could benefit Obama – New Bern Sun Journal « Abetterdogkennel.net

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://dog-training-blogs.com/chattanooga-tn/2012/01/romneys-obama-dog-whistle-bagnews-notes/ Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes « Chattanooga Dog Training In your Home

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Weldon-Berger/1075193081 Weldon Berger

    “No person except a natural born citizen, or a citizen of the United States, at the time of the adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that office who shall not have attained to the age of thirty-five years, and been fourteen years a resident within the United States.”

    George Romney was a citizen by birth (because his parents were citizens) who met the residency requirement, just one who was born outside the US. Same with McCain, who was born in Panama.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Weldon-Berger/1075193081 Weldon Berger

    It’s a nice little double entendre for a campaign making the argument that the president hasn’t done enough to fix the economy and that what he has done hasn’t worked. The racial implication is there to be found, but the sentiment would work equally well for any other opponent.

  • http://abetterdogkennel.net/wordpress/2012/01/daniels-speech-out-of-step-with-times-south-bend-tribune/ Daniels’ speech out of step with times – South Bend Tribune « Abetterdogkennel.net

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://dog-training-blogs.com/lake-norman-nc/2012/01/gop-responses-to-state-of-the-union-lack-vision-for-energy-future-huffington-post-blog/ GOP Responses to State of the Union Lack Vision for Energy Future – Huffington Post (blog) « Lake Norman huntersville Dog Trainer

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://dog-training-blogs.com/charlotte-nc/2012/01/31/challenge-campaign-of-insults-slurs-vs-obama-chicago-sun-times/ Challenge campaign of insults, slurs vs. Obama – Chicago Sun-Times « Charlotte Dog Training In Your Home Dog News Blog

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://abetterdogkennel.net/wordpress/2012/02/newt-gingrich-and-the-art-of-racial-dog-whistling-news-one/ Newt Gingrich and the Art of Racial Dog Whistling – News One « Abetterdogkennel.net

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://abetterdogkennel.net/wordpress/2012/02/the-rise-of-the-new-hate-huffington-post-blog/ The Rise Of The New Hate – Huffington Post (blog) « Abetterdogkennel.net

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://dog-training-blogs.com/gastonia-nc/political-finger-pointing-chicago-tribune/ Political finger-pointing – Chicago Tribune « Dog Training Gastonia

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://dog-training-blogs.com/gwinnett-ga/2012/02/column-%e2%80%94-obama-v-brewer-is-a-tiff-blown-all-out-of-proportion-hollandsentinel-com/ COLUMN — Obama v. Brewer is a tiff blown all out of proportion – HollandSentinel.com « Gwinnett Dog Training In Your Home

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://dog-training-blogs.com/gastonia-nc/nation-digest-wikileaks-court-martial-ordered-obama-unveils-veterans-job-austin-american-statesman/ Nation Digest: WikiLeaks court-martial ordered; Obama unveils veterans job … – Austin American-Statesman « Dog Training Gastonia

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]

  • http://abetterdogkennel.net/wordpress/2012/02/foster-farms-new-lower-sodium-100-percent-whole-grain-chicken-corn-dog-looks-marketwatch-press-release/ Foster Farms’ New Lower-Sodium, 100 Percent Whole Grain Chicken Corn Dog Looks … – MarketWatch (press release) « Abetterdogkennel.net

    [...] Romney’s Obama Dog Whistle? – BagNews Notes [...]