BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Friday, May 25, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



August 24, 2011

The Colonel’s Hat

I want to rejoice over a scene like this, as if I, too, had stumbled upon and donned the Colonel’s hat, or got to share the moment with my comrade who did. But then, how often does a photo like simply serve as the high water mark for the hopes of the revolution?

NYT Slideshow: The Battle for Libya

(photo: Bryan Denton for The New York Times caption: A rebel fighter in Tripoli wore a military-style hat like the one often seen on the head of Colonel Qaddafi himself. The rebel was also carrying a scepter and had an enormous gold chain hanging around his neck.)

  • omen

    the reason for your cynicism?

    • http://www.bagnewsnotes.com Michael Shaw

      Lack of political infrastructure; tribal nature; human nature; Sarkozy payback; wobbly Egypt; oil grab. I don’t know. 

  • omen

    i don’t know why my comments keep disappearing after confirmation of posting.

  • omen

    i don’t know why my comments keep disappearing after confirmation of posting.

  • T Perky

    I really liked the guy, myself, he was funny, and surprisingly fluent in English. Of all the scenes on the tv of bombs and fires and guns, this was the first guy that made the “protesters” seem like real people.

    It was interesting that besides the hat, another thing found in Quaddafi’s compound was a photo album with pics of Condi Rice. Reminds me of bin Laden’s porn collection. 

    • omen

      i too appreciated his giddiness. i shared in his euphoria. it’s like he won his freedom by seizing the king’s crown and scepter. but i fear he is being set up as a clown, a “loser” destined for failure.

      in the wall to wall coverage yesterday of western journalist being released and rebels taking over tripoli, we heard more about the travails and inconvenience suffered by one white reporter. i’m glad he was released, but, come on, being detained five days doesn’t compare to living under tyranny for 40 years. where are those stories? just like in iraq, we are not getting the libyan perspective from corporate media. what we do get are portrayals that set people up as clowns or terrorists, angry arabs running around with guns. there is a dearth of any portrayals that respects libyans as worthy of dignity or meriting sympathy.

  • LanceThruster

     I love the smile of the guy in the blue shorts. That’s the grin I would have had, looking at the other guy and admiring his way cool memento.

  • tinwoman

    He’s also got a lot of gold there—they’re looting.  They’re not heroes.  And they’re going to destroy Libya.

    • omen

      guess who looted the gold in the first place?

    • LanceThruster

      It is no accident that the man who created the slogan ‘Liberty! Fraternity! Equality!’ was guillotined by the Revolution which championed his slogan. [hat tip to  – http://factsnotfairies.blogspot.com/ 

      Regardless of how the aftermath of the deposition of Gaddafi turns out, I think they are heroes. I remember early on hearing an NPR report about how a rebel commander with much bravado had sent his forces against a loyalist counterforce, and the rebel forces were coming back decimated against a better armed and better trained Gaddafi military. Their bloodshed did not involve the spoils of war, just the brutality of it.

      Yet they were willing to make those sacrifices because the desire to be out from under dictatorial rule was so compelling. And I’m someone who feels that the case against Gaddafi and the Lockerbie airline bombing was largely trumped up.

      As omen remarked, he was not the one who plundered the gold in the first place.

  • omen

    hey, here’s a photo of the daughter gaddafi’s mermaid bed:

    http://news.yahoo.com/rebels-looters-target-gadhafi-family-homes-215327125.html

  • omen

    hey, here’s a photo of the daughter gaddafi’s mermaid bed:

    http://news.yahoo.com/rebels-looters-target-gadhafi-family-homes-215327125.html

  • http://reciprocity-failure.blogspot.com Stan B.

    And who can forget all those triumphant photos of then President elect Obama full of wonder, anticipation and… HOPE- who then promptly proceeded to cave on just about every damn thing he ever promised, campaigned on or stood for…

  • omen

    juan cole suggests otherwise:

    The secret of the uprising’s final days of success lay in a popular revolt in the working-class districts of the capital, which did most of the hard work of throwing off the rule of secret police and military cliques. It succeeded so well that when revolutionary brigades entered the city from the west, many encountered little or no resistance, and they walked right into the center of the capital.
    [...]
    I was moreover convinced that the generality of Libyans were attracted by the revolution and by the idea of a political opening, and that there was no great danger to national unity here.

    that doesn’t sound like crippling tribal polarization.

    indonesia, with their oil wealth, was predicted they wouldn’t succeed as a democracy either.

    it’s disconcerting that so many people are predicting failure. the alternative condemns libyans to live under dictatorship forever.

    a few months back, rebels put together an oil deal with qatar. the oil money got distributed down to residents in order to stave off families from starving, (as well as helped to fund the resistance) helping to mitigate what could have turned into a greater humanitarian crisis in the middle of a conflict. egypt as well as southern europe can’t afford for libya to devolve into a failed state. i just heard about turkey sending millions in aid as well as advisors to the rebels.

    re oil grab.. i run across lefty sites where critics are obsessed with libya’s oil. it’s as if that’s the only subject that matters. they completely overlook and ignore the oppression libyans have suffered. they rail against nato yet neglect to mention it was libyans who petitioned the international community for intervention. it was libyans who called for a no-fly zone. critics rarely address a libyan perspective or include libyan voices. inherent in these kinds of arguments from critics is an attitude that they know better than libyans themselves what’s in libya’s best interest and betrays a bias that considers libyans incapable of self rule. pepe escobar complains that libya has signaled it wont deal with russia or china for oil deals. this gets presented as somehow a great outrage. where’s the outrage for how libyans have been mistreated for decades? it’s their oil. they can do anything they want with it.  of course russia and china are going to get cut out when they’ve sided with gaddafi continuing his regime. why should the rebels reward countries who’ve sided against them?

    personally, i worry about graft and eventual corruption by elites in the country might deny everyday people benefit from their own resource, but i trust libyans themselves will address that themselves. yes, there is a threat that the tnc or other officials doing the bidding of the west will attempt to install neoliberal policies, but gaddafi himself was instituting neoliberal policies. that threat alone shouldn’t preclude libyans from fighting to gain independence.