BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 24, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



September 23, 2010

A Matter of Life and Death

Dennis Brack-Pool/Getty Images

If the photo above — the one that popped up in so many “picture of the day” galleries yesterday — is the money shot, I think the one below is just as interesting.

Why? Because of the way Obama’s embrace of this women with cancer is juxtaposed with such an impersonal angle on Health Secretary Sebellius.

It’s all well and good for Obama to descend on America’s middle class backyards in an attempt to look less distant, aloof, cerebral, etc. What the “cancer woman” photo does, however (beyond offering a President who is warmer and more “in touch,” this being of limited value as an all-too-obvious piece of PR) is show a visceral connection between Obama, the public and the health care legislation he invested so much political capital in (and yes, scored such a major victory with). Sure, it’s only one picture, but in embracing this woman, Obama actually and finally interjects a show of heart into an issue that is, after all, a matter of life-and-death, and also, forgawdsakes, offers up some rebuttal to the incessant GOP drone that it’s “Obamacare” that is ailing America.

(image 2: Jim Young/Reuters. U.S. President Barack Obama (L) speaks to Gail O’Brien (C) who attended a town hall meeting in the yard of a residential house as Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius leaves the event in Falls Church, Virginia, September 22, 2010.)

  • Gasho

    I appreciate your comments, Bag, in that healthcare reform is going to help millions, but if I look at this through my BagNewsNotes eyes and imagine the marker lines being drawn on the shot, I have to say that I’d see Obama leaning AWAY from this woman energetically.

    It looks like she’s going in for the power hug, and he’s giving her the “not so fast”, “hold on”, “slow down, lady”..

    And the guy in the background – presumably her husband (?) – seems over vigilant in a non-trusting way, which may be contributing to the ‘distance’ that Obama is trying to achieve.. but it’s not the warm and fuzzy personal touch that I get from your comments (which is too bad).

    • http://bagnews.com/staff/#mshaw Michael Shaw

      When you really attend to the body language, you’re right, also showing the “warm and fuzzy” problem remains. I wasn’t sure, though, if they guy in back was hubby, or secret service.

    • Gasho

      Hubby v. Secret Service: Hard to tell, but he’s pretty darned interested, that’s for sure !!

  • Vvoter

    This is one of BO’s Jesus poses. Google image “Jesus and woman”.

    Gasho’s got it, though. His right hand is holding her back.

    Secret service.