BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Monday, February 13, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



September 9, 2010

Equating Muslims with the Threat of Violence? You’re Kidding, Right?

In the current atmosphere — given the attacks on Obama’s religious status and the NYC Islamic center, coupled with the obsessive preoccupation with the small-time Florida preacher intent on holding a 9/11 Quran burning — I can’t see where a photo like this is very constructive.

It showed up in Wednesday’s WAPO “Day in Photos” slideshow.  The context had to do with the precarious status of the Sept. 18th Afghan election, the caption (below) also highlighting threats by the Taliban against the vote.  Given the power of pictures and the way they tend to run together in an overarching news narrative, the skull caps, the primitive setting, the smile, and, of course, the gun pointed right in our Western faces, can only add fuel right now — published three days before the 9/11 anniversary — to the raging paranoia equating Muslims, and Islam, with the threat of violence.

(Photo: Raheb Homavandi/Reuters. Caption: A boy plays with a toy pistol in Mohajerin, Afghanistan. Observers warn that Taliban threats, shuttered polling centers and warnings of widespread fraud are clouding hopes for Afghanistan’s Sept. 18 parliamentary election, a key test of an already-fragile democracy.)

  • thirdeye pushpin

    What are the other boys looking at? and why is the photographer only drawing attention from the boy with the gun?

  • black dog barking

    In my time, in my part of the world, little boys carried shiny plastic repro’s of Colt .45 revolvers and wore ersatz coonskin caps. Plus ca change.

    B Dylan, about 50 years ago:

    You must leave now, take what you need, you think will last
    But whatever you wish to keep, you better grab it fast
    Yonder stands your orphan with his gun
    Crying like a fire in the sun
    Look out the saints are comin’ through
    And it’s all over now, Baby Blue

    What’re you looking at, old man?

  • thirdeye pushpin

    and I thought he wrote the song as way of getting a dig in at donavan…

  • and the sign

    the words of the prophets are written

  • electrical banana

    a sudden craze
    is bound to be
    the very next phase

  • Megan

    You know, I can barely stand it when my nephews point their fingers at me (like a gun). This picture feels a million times worse.

    The urge to say “No shooters,” smooth his hair and feed him remains the same.

  • black dog barking
  • black dog barking

    Correction. The shiny six-shooter-esque toys of my childhood were made of pot metal. Plastic, we learned with Ben Braddock, was the future. (link also works for Sounds of Silence)

  • Paul W. Luscher

    Ya got a point. Actually a photo of an American kid doing this would be very representative of our country–given the eagerness with which we use firearms on each other.

  • http://www.nocaptionneeded.com lucaites

    Photographs of children from the Middle East playing with toy guns are almost a dime a dozen in the mainstream media and have been since at least the invasion of Iraq. What is very rare are pictures of kids in the west, and especially in US, doing the same thing. That’s not to say that our kids don’t play with toy guns, much to the contrary, but we don’t seem to have the same fetish (at least anymore … my family photo album shows me as child in the 1950s with several such images) of showing them doing it … That phenomenon deserves comment in and of itself (see links below for where I’ve addressed this on several occasions). I think Bag’s point however, and it shouldn’t be scanted here, is that doing it at this precise moment in time is especially irresponsible of the media, particularly given that they don’t seem to have any specific news value.

    http://www.nocaptionneeded.com/?p=1036
    http://www.nocaptionneeded.com/?p=68
    http://www.nocaptionneeded.com/?p=5574
    http://www.nocaptionneeded.com/?p=1446

  • g

    First thing I thought of were pictures of American kids posing with guns at NRA rallies. Like right here at the Bag:

    http://www.bagnewsnotes.com/2010/02/cpac-1-kids-with-guns/