BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 24, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



June 10, 2010

Oil Blowout: The Point, If Not Clear, Is That People Are Burning Up

The public’s frustration over the oil disaster, coupled with the impotent response of the government and the “powers-that-be” only intensifies the feeling of horror and disconnection we feel in the face of AP photographer Charlie Reidel’s mummified birds, or the act, captured by EPA photographer Jim Lo Scalzo this morning, of this woman — identified as a fisherwoman from Texas — pouring an oil-like substance over herself in the middle of a Senate Energy Committee hearing featuring the Interior Secretary.

It’s not just the government that is not quite getting it, though. It’s also the media that is pulling its punches. What makes these images so terrifying and threatening is how much this woman, Diane Wilson, simulates the act of someone preparing to burn herself to death.

If you notice which photos the media is circulating, however (as evidenced by these slideshows at Zimbio, Houston Chronicle and HuffPo), they mostly steer clear of the act of dousing (especially involving the head), thus running from connection to self-immolation. (And, let’s not even get started on the lack of pictures of the victims incinerated on that oil rig.)

If people — having been marginalized down to nothing by America Inc. — have just about had it, it’s only through the small outbreaks of visual evidence that we can feel ourselves burning up.

(photo: Jim Lo Scalzo/EPA)

  • bystander

    Am I remiss in observing how seductive this act of self-dousing appears to me? There is something about Watson’s expression as she pours oil on herself. This visual is simply stunning.

    Equally compelling is the woman to Watson’s right in blue; particularly, the first and last frame. If I wanted to guess what it felt like to be a witness to Watson’s statement, I gravitate to the expression of the woman in blue. I may not be interpreting her correctly but I sense this deadening or helplessness… I find her affectless expression to be more demanding of my attention than even the expression of the woman to “blue’s” right.

    What a loaded set of images. They are going to roll around in my head for quite some time to come.

  • http://keepittrill.blogspot.com/ Kit (Keep It Trill)

    I think this catastrophe is the saddest I’ve experienced in my lifetime. I love nature and all that God made. It pains me that avaricous-based deregulation and negligence has resulted in the death of an ocean… and perhaps the others due to the toxic oil dispersants used. I’m not even sure this planet has much of a future anymore as we know it, and have blogged extensively on this the past three weeks to make sense of the insanity.

    And the photos here, compelling.

  • http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/id/151271 yg

    oh my gosh, googling for details i realize with a start that i’ve seen her before. she gave a speech on cspan discussing her book.she has a long history of fighting polluters. this never ending calamity must make her feel like her life’s work as been all for naught. oh, the heartbreak.

  • http://www.leosigh.blogspot.com Leo Sigh

    I’m just amazed how she got into a Senate hearing with a bottle of oil? Have you tried taking a teaspoon of water onto a plane lately?

  • bystander

    So, Michael, is this woman Diane Watson, or Diane Wilson (as yg suggests). HuffPo identifies her as Diane Wilson.

    • http://bagnews.com/staff/#mshaw Michael Shaw

      Whoops, correction made. Congress on my mind, I guess.