Archives About Staff BagNews is dedicated to visual politics, media literacy and the analysis of news images.
May 30, 2010

Alan Chin: Dover Air Force Base

December 3, 2009: The remains of Cpl. Kenneth R. Nichols, Jr., Chrisman, Ill., U.S. Army, killed Dec. 1 in Kunar province, Afghanistan, of wounds from an attack  involving small arms and rocket-propelled grenades, and Lance Cpl. Jonathan Taylor, Jacksonville, Fla., U.S.  Marine Corps, killed Dec. 1 in Helmand province, Afghanistan.
December 3, 2009: The remains of Cpl. Kenneth R. Nichols, Jr., Chrisman, Ill., U.S. Army, killed Dec. 1 in Kunar province, Afghanistan, of wounds from an attack involving small arms and rocket-propelled grenades, and Lance Cpl. Jonathan Taylor, Jacksonville, Fla., U.S. Marine Corps, killed Dec. 1 in Helmand province, Afghanistan.
May 4, 2010: Air Force "Dignified Transfer" Team on board the 747 which returned the remains of Airman  First Class Austin H. Gates Benson, Hellertown, PA, U.S. Air  Force. Benson died May 3 near Khyber, Afghanistan, of injuries sustained  from a  non-combat-related incident.
May 4, 2010: Air Force "Dignified Transfer" Team on board the 747 which returned the remains of Airman First Class Austin H. Gates Benson, Hellertown, PA, U.S. Air Force. Benson died May 3 near Khyber, Afghanistan, of injuries sustained from a non-combat-related incident.
May 4, 2010: The remains of Sgt. Anthony Oneal Magee, Hattiesburg, MS, U.S. Army, died April 27 in Landstuhl, Germany, from wounds sustained in an  indirect fire attack April 24 at COS (Contingency Operating Site) Kalsu, Iraq.
<div id="TixyyLink"><a href="http://www.ledger-enquirer.com/2010/05/13/1121852_2-69-soldiers-remember-fallen.html#ixzz0pTRrBbgx"></a></div>
May 4, 2010: The remains of Sgt. Anthony Oneal Magee, Hattiesburg, MS, U.S. Army, died April 27 in Landstuhl, Germany, from wounds sustained in an indirect fire attack April 24 at COS (Contingency Operating Site) Kalsu, Iraq.
December 16, 2009: "Dignified Transfer" Team carries the remains of Tech. Sgt. Anthony C. Campbell, Florence, KY., U.S. Air Force, who died Dec. 15 in Helmand province, Afghanistan, of wounds sustained from  the detonation of an improvised explosive device.
December 16, 2009: "Dignified Transfer" Team carries the remains of Tech. Sgt. Anthony C. Campbell, Florence, KY., U.S. Air Force, who died Dec. 15 in Helmand province, Afghanistan, of wounds sustained from the detonation of an improvised explosive device.
May 4, 2010: Capt. Amber Millerchip, U.S. Air Force awaits the unloading of the remains of Airman  First Class Austin H. Gates Benson, Hellertown, PA, U.S. Air Force. Benson died May 3 near Khyber, Afghanistan, of injuries sustained from a  non-combat-related incident.
May 4, 2010: Capt. Amber Millerchip, U.S. Air Force awaits the unloading of the remains of Airman First Class Austin H. Gates Benson, Hellertown, PA, U.S. Air Force. Benson died May 3 near Khyber, Afghanistan, of injuries sustained from a non-combat-related incident.
December 3, 2009: "Dignified Transfer" Team about to carry the remains of Cpl. Kenneth R. Nichols, Jr., Chrisman,  Ill., U.S. Army, killed Dec. 1 in Kunar province, Afghanistan, of  wounds from an attack  involving small arms and rocket-propelled  grenades, and Lance Cpl. Jonathan Taylor, Jacksonville, Fla., U.S.   Marine Corps, killed Dec. 1 in Helmand province, Afghanistan.
December 3, 2009: "Dignified Transfer" Team about to carry the remains of Cpl. Kenneth R. Nichols, Jr., Chrisman, Ill., U.S. Army, killed Dec. 1 in Kunar province, Afghanistan, of wounds from an attack involving small arms and rocket-propelled grenades, and Lance Cpl. Jonathan Taylor, Jacksonville, Fla., U.S. Marine Corps, killed Dec. 1 in Helmand province, Afghanistan.

On Memorial Day, BagNewsOriginals take you to Dover Air Force base, where the dead American soldiers of the Iraq and Afghan Wars are flown in. This post also marks the first in the BAG’s Focus on the Afghan War, waged both in Asia and in the nation’s psyche.

–Michael Shaw

I signed up in December to photograph the return of the bodies of American soldiers killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, and they approved my request. Bush never allowed us to document it, and Obama finally changed the policy last year. A small victory for free speech and access, although it’s very limited.

They only give you about 6 hours notice before it happens, and the families have to approve media access; they do this quickly, in most cases the soldier was killed only a few hours before.

I went to my first one on December 3rd. After I received their email and confirmed, I rushed onto the New Jersey turnpike and headed south on a crisp and cold winter afternoon, shafts of light from the setting sun puncturing through the low-hanging clouds. After a while there was just a strip of gorgeous orange above the horizon, and then it was dark. It took almost three hours to get to Dover.

Two other photographers showed up, and we were met by Major Shannon Mann of the Air Force, a surprisingly friendly Public Affairs Officer. She had googled me and therefore knew a lot about me, had seen some of my work online; I’d never dealt with anyone from the military in such a normal way before.

But that was the nice part. Otherwise the rules for our coverage are pretty strict: No photos, or even contact, with the families. No moving away from the designated media area; no pictures of anything else on the base; no getting close to or on board the plane; no lingering around after the brief process is finished.

They gave us a short briefing about all that, a dog sniffed through our equipment, then we were taken onto the airfield and assigned a spot about fifty feet away from the plane. It was a big 747 modified for cargo so that the entire nose of it opened, from which a loading ramp jutted out with the two American-flag draped “transfer cases” on it. They don’t call them caskets or coffins because these are “body-boxes” that get re-used.

It was pretty stark in the dim light with an almost full moon; at first there was no one there. Then the bus carrying the families showed up but it was choreographed so they got out on the side away from us so we could not see them. One white van, what they call the “transfer vehicle,” was parked on the tarmac and one soldier, a young woman, stood next to it. She is the “Transfer Vehicle Guide,” whose ceremonial role it is to close the van’s back doors after the bodies are loaded on board.

The procedure began with high-ranking officers and the pall-bearer details appearing, marching in formation. Since there were two dead that night, Cpl. Kenneth Nichols, Jr., of Chrisman, Illinois, US Army, and Lance Cpl. Jonathan Taylor, of Jacksonville, Florida, US Marine Corps, both killed in Afghanistan, there were two separate teams, one from the Army, the other of Marines, dressed in their different uniforms.

The Army went first, boarded the stairs onto the airplane, and emerged out the front. The loading ramp then lowered onto ground level with the “transfer case” and the seven pall-bearers carried the body past the saluting officers, into the waiting van. The Marines then repeated the same. Not a sound could be heard from the hidden family members just a few feet from us on the other side of their bus. Another time, I could hear a woman, probably the wife or the mother, crying a terrible wail that was the only sound on the airfield.

The movements of the soldiers were slow and deliberate, giving us plenty of time to photograph. As soon as it was over, though, they drove us back to our cars, and wryly remarked that they would see us again soon. And they were right of course; I’ve been down there five times now, a bit frustrated at the limits of access, but also unsettlingly drawn into the ritual.

This is how American soldiers who are killed in action come home.

–Alan Chin

PHOTOGRAPHS by ALAN CHIN / facingchange.org

captions– Top: May 4, 2010: Aircraft carrying the remains of Airman First Class Austin H. Gates Benson, Hellertown, PA, U.S. Air Force. Benson died May 3 near Khyber, Afghanistan, of injuries sustained from a non-combat-related incident.

Middle: December 16, 2009: Major Shannon Mann, USAF, awaits the unloading of the remains of Tech. Sgt. Anthony C. Campbell, Florence, KY., U.S. Air Force, who died Dec. 15 in Helmand province, Afghanistan, of wounds sustained from the detonation of an improvised explosive device.

Bottom: May 4, 2010: Left to right, A civilian contractor, a wife of an officer, and Captain Amber Millerchip, USAF, salute the remains of Airman First Class Austin H. Gates Benson, Hellertown, PA, U.S. Air Force. Benson died May 3 near Khyber, Afghanistan, of injuries sustained from a non-combat-related incident.

About the Photographer

Alan Chin

Alan Chin was born and raised in New York City’s Chinatown. Alan Chin was born and raised in New York City’s Chinatown. Since 1996, he has worked in China, the former Yugoslavia, Afghanistan, Iraq, Egypt, and throughout the Middle East and Central Asia. In the US, Alan has explored the South, following the historic trail of the civil rights movement and the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, covered multiple presidential campaigns, and the Occupy Wall Street movement. He is a contributing photographer to Newsweek/Daily Beast and The New York Times, a member of Facing Change: Documenting America (FCDA), and an editor at Newsmotion.org. You can see all Alan's posts for BagNews here.

  • Bill

    I find the prevalence of using air freight contractors to perform this somber task to be unsettling: Kalitta Air and Atlas Air figuring prominently in these images, with the omnipresent Evergreen International in the background. Everybody profits in war except the troops!

  • DennisQ

    The 747 in the first picture could almost be a shark attempting to swallow whole that ladder contraption thing. The machines dwarf the humanity of the situation, as if the scene were about them. That’s close to the theme of Randall Jarrell’s “Death of the Ball Turret Gunner.”

    The pictures convey the coldness and silence of the scene. I can hear the sound of the soldiers as they march and halt to the command of their leader. The senior people salute crisply. Alan Chin observes, . . . I could hear a woman, probably the wife or the mother, crying a terrible wail that was the only sound on the airfield. . . .”

    • Charlene

      A shark, yes, or maybe a huge reptile with its extended tongue and captured prey, soon to be flipped back and swallowed.

      And that wailing. I did that once, at the funeral of my mother. It was a truly otherworldly feeling to know that this noise was coming from me, but to have no control over it even though I was keenly aware that I was embarrassing myself and making other people uncomfortable. It was as if the voices of a long history of mourning women had descended on me. In this case, all the strict rules and ritual of the “transfer” couldn’t hide the grief of a woman who wasn’t allowed to be seen but was heard.

  • http://sozadee.blogspot.com/ Vigilante

    There us not enough photography of U.S. KIA & WIA on site in Afghanistan, IMO. I remember the effect of on the ground photography of the Tet offensive in Vietnamistan. It was unsanitary and cathartic.

  • bks

    George W. Bush should be stripped naked and staked out on top of
    a fire-ant nest each Memorial Day until the troops come back from
    Iraq and Afghanistan.

    –bks

    • JAMES FISKE

      BKAS…IT IS YOU THAT SHOULD BE STRIPPED IF I WERE OF THE SAME FRAM OF MIND AS YOU CRAZZY SICK MINDING INDIVIDUALS APPEAR TO REFLECT DISRESPECT FOR OUR TROOPS, NATION AND NEED FOR NATIONAL SECURITY….WHICH HAS BEEN WEAKENED BY PEOPLE LIKE YOU!!!!

      AS A VETERAN….YOU ARE THE LOWEST OF THE LOWEST MINDED FOOLS!!!!

  • Kathleen Pearce

    My heart goes out to all those who have suffered the loss of a loved one, especially one caused by these senseless and unwinnable wars. Bush, Cheney et al., most definately should be held accountable for the deaths of American men and women and the innocent civilians killed in Iraq and Afghanistan. Bring our troops home now and take good care of them! My thoughts, prayers and gratitude are with those who mourn today.

  • Gary Austin

    The tragedy of what Bush/Cheney/Rumsfield have done cannot ever be undone. The horrors of their arrogance and contempt for Americans will continue to mutate and kill. The religious, military, industrial complex will survive…and the beat goes on.

  • GERALD LOMBARDI

    WHERE IS THE OIL? GULF OF MEXICO

  • NoContest

    You know, I’ve said it before, I don’t like the invasive way Alan Chin gets in people’s faces to take his “Goat” photo’s.

    What am i talking about Alan? How does it feel to be a goatherder. ooops. Control-Alt-Delete by daddy.

    • Alan Chin

      Goats? I don’t see any goats here, nor do I see myself as a goatherder. My family historically had chickens, and a water buffalo, but no goats. And they got out of China so I could grow up as an effete urban intellectual, albeit one on various scholarships and otherwise benefiting from “socialist” largesse such as free school lunch and a bus pass.

      Invasive? I detail the rules and regulations by which the military allows us to work. I chafe at the limits of this restricted access but I abide by it fully. I have worked hard in my entire career to be discreet, respectful, and honest in how I photograph.

      Don’t take my word for it. Why don’t you come with me for a day or two when I work, and you tell me how you think I do it. And then you can write, to the world, your opinion right here. This is a serious and open invitation.

      Part of the BagNews mission which I fully agree with, always have, is greater transparency in how images are made and published. So let’s knock that wall down between you, reader, and me, photographer.

    • past11thour

      …rede deskript uv ‘bottom’ pict-ur…luk agin…re-reed…(except4GatesBenson)U-R th’t-her-gotes’ morelative)

  • Tony Bryant

    I think the courtesy and solemnity with which these fine young Americans are treated in death contrasts, sadly, with the seemingly careless and pointless manner in which the Politicians send them into in action.
    All power to Alan Chin; the sad procedure he has documented here is the inevitable consequence of any War, but of course the price is principally and eternally paid by relatives who would otherwise be the only witnesses, but for Alan’s camera.

  • http://honor-escort.com Elin Whitney-Smith

    Thanks for the photos and the story.

    My late husband was an Honor Escort after World War II. He escorted 76 fallen soldiers. They had been buried on the battlefields where they fell and when the war was over the families had the option to bring their dead home.

    I have written a treatment for a screen play that is previewing at http://honor-escort.com

    Thanks again for the moving pictures and story.

    elin

  • Joie Gates

    Thank you Mr. Chin for recording, in such a beautiful manner, my son’s return home.
    Being there in person was an honor.
    It was also heart breaking, soul shattering and life changing..
    My thanks go to those who honored his, and our, sacrifice.
    Our loss knows no end.

    We will never forget.

    Best regards,

    Joie Gates
    Mother of A1C Austin Gates Benson

Originals Archive Archives