BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 24, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



February 21, 2010

And on the Seventh Day, They Rested

Prayers Afghanistan.jpg

Thank God Jesus has our back over there in Afghanistan

(photo: Pier Paolo Cito/A.P. caption: U.S. soldiers of the 1st Battalion, 17th Infantry Regiment, 5th Brigade, 2nd Infantry Division, kneel as father Carl Subler, U.S. Cpt. Chaplain from Versailles, Ohio, celebrates a mass service in an outpost in the Badula Qulp area, West of Lashkar Gah in Helmand province, southernAfghanistan, Sunday, Feb. 21, 2010)

  • Bill

    If I’m not mistaken a battalion is 1000 soldiers. Only 7 Roman Catholics showed up for mass? I assume an approximately equal number show up for Protestant services? This seems low to me. All the talk about God and Country and less than 2% of the military are practicing Christians? Can anyone comment? So much for the ol’ “no atheists in foxholes” saw. Or is faith another casualty of this war?

  • eddiberto

    A Battalion has no set number of troops. My entire Battalion consisted of no more than 93 soldiers when we deployed. The caption reads that Mass was being performed in some outpost, not a large base or FOB. If these soldiers were on a base, it would be inside and there would be a building. It would also be packed. Out here on the outposts, the chaplains try to bring in as many soldiers as they can, but the problem is that missions run all day long. Chances are these joes were off and feel pretty lucky to be able to attend.

  • lytom

    Hmmm, are they going to be merciful to the human beings they encounter the same day?
    Blood is on their hands and nothing will wash that! Not medals, not parades for heroes will make them the same…

  • Books Alive

    Prayer in your daily life is important to Catholics. We start the day with prayers or Mass, and many will offer up their daily activities as petitions. That’s what I was taught. I think the photo illustrates the men’s sacrifice, as it is they who have our back.

  • Gasho

    Mixing religion with war is SO SUPER DICEY. Think in terms of cognitive dissonance. You’re dealing with metaphysics, so certainty is not possible; morality, so your actions are being judged; eternal judgement, so you’d better get it right; and on top of all that you’re killing people so you have to at least feel a little twinge of doubt about how well you’re doing in God’s eyes.
    I’ve always thought that GWB’s born-again-to-get-elected-and-start-a-war was quite possibly the most hypocritical thing ever done. I often picture him standing before Jesus (his iconography, not mine) and having the *TALK*. If he even is a 1% believer, he’d tear out his own beating heart and eat it out of sheer anxiety after what he’s done.

  • Gasho

    I’d like to comment more on the image.. there’s so much there.
    Seen from above, the men are on their knees in the dirt. We’re taking God’s vantage point here, which can be a little uncomfortable in itself.
    Beyond that, there are 3 major elements in the picture: The earthen slab, the fire pit, and the noose. Look at them. The slab says “grave” all over it. It’s a little larger than an individual’s grave, but that adds to it’s weight. The fire pit looks like it might be an instant portal to hell, built right into the landscape of this service here. Finally, the thick black strap, complete with a loop at the dangling end, hanging from the end of the wild-west style post. Creepy.
    All in all, it reeks of “judgement” as opposed to “salvation”.

  • Brown

    The purple chasuble marks the Lenten season and should remind us of our unworthiness. May the deity have mercy on us all for invading and occupying Afghanistan and Iraq.

  • thomas

    It’s weird that the revulsion I feel at the actual conduct of the leaders of our religious and governmental institutions must reside so closely to the reverence I have for the founding principles which said institutions claim to embody.

  • Aurora

    Yes. What I was struggling to formulate.
    Thank you.

  • Aurora

    That is an unusual color for vestments. If seen/read as violet, it would signify the First Sunday of Lent. On the other hand, it seems more royal blue…specific to Catholic chaplins serving the military?
    So, the spot of color anchors the image and lifts the sensual/sensory/emotional/spiritual dimension out of the mundane; beautiful and pregnant with symbol.
    I think the noose is a horse/mule tether on a hitching post…or not? hard to tell how high off the ground in relation to the head of the priest.
    Creeps me a bit how the posture of the soldiers, at the Consecration of the Mass happening here, echoes images of Abu Ghraib prisoners…

  • David

    You don’t know how those soldiers have dealt with their experiences in Afghanistan, lytom. Maybe they have killed people, but maybe they have not; one of them might be attached as a medic. I don’t think it’s fair to assume they have blood on their hands and it’s worse to accuse them of it without additional information.