BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Monday, February 13, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



September 10, 2009

More Health Care Joint Session: Obama’s Psych 101

McCain-health-care-Jt.-Sess.jpg

I think what inflames Republican senators more than anything is Obama’s capacity to draw true feelings of empathy and concern out of them (thus throwing them into heightened, if momentary conflict with their hard-baked selves). Obama does it just often enough to keep them both off balance and on notice — the way he did last night intentionally singing out Ted Kennedy’s legislative partnerships with Grassley, Hatch and, in the very instant above, McCain.

By the way, I’ve read very little about the profound risk and, yes, audacity, of Obama daring to convene a joint session of Congress over health care — especially while perceived to be back on his heels. (And, because he stuck it last night, I don’t we’re going to.) The strategy, however, was vintage Obama in perfect tune with his “keep your enemies closer.”

And, to the extent he was in the Republican’s face last night — dangling carrots and swinging sticks at an alternately dizzying pace, the national audience in witness — he demonstrated that August, almost universally acknowledged as a set-back, was as much Obama letting out the rope for a repressed and tea bag-infused GOP to hang itself.

(screen shot: BNN via MSNBC)

  • Tena

    If what Obama said to Orrin Hatch didn’t get to him, then Orrin Hatch has no heart.
    And yeah it drives them nuts. The moral argument Obama made was perfect. It’s what I wanted to hear and it was perfect.

  • mcc

    I was fascinated by that moment where he calls out the thing he liked from McCain’s health care plan during the campaign, and McCain gave that little stand, smile, thumbs-up. I don’t know how to interpret McCain’s mental state in that moment. It seemed to take him a moment to react, almost as if he was going, oh, hey, people are looking at me now, I’d better react for the cameras. Has McCain commented since the speech last night?

  • g

    I think McCain really, really has a personal dislike of Obama, but somewhere within him his nobler self is battling against giving in to that. So he does occasionally stand on principle, he does attempt to be an “honorable” opposition. As an older, more established pol, I think he has dedication to the system. But you can tell it is just sticking in his craw.
    Has McCain commented since the speech last night?
    Not on this, IFAIK, but he did speak out to rebuke Joe Wilson.

  • charlie

    McCain looks impressed.

  • http://profile.typepad.com/msobel marc sobel

    I have been battling with three theories of what Obama has been up to:
    1) He wants a Bad Max industry written bill in order to get the industry money (sellout)
    2) He is just screwing it up (after executing an almost flawless plan (fuckup)
    3) He is giving the Republicans enough rope. (Neo-Leninist as in the capitalists will sell you the rope you use to hang them )
    I was heartened to see you use the metaphor of the rope.
    Metaphors be with you.

  • Books Alive

    I was watching Grassley whenever C-Span turned to him. One face he showed was set in a stoney scowl, which quickly turned into the wide grin when he realized he might be on camera. This isn’t quite the stubborn look of last night, but it comes close.
    Sen Grassley

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p00e5523476cc8834 DennisQ

    McCain looks better in this picture than he has in a long time. He was all punched out at the height of the presidential campaign – what a difference a year makes!
    I agree with the above comment that Charlie made – McCain looks impressed. It’s a politician’s acknowledgement of the skills of another politician. It does not imply approval; just an appreciation of watching Obama at work.