BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 24, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



September 1, 2009

End of Life: A Process, Not An Act

Moore-hospice-Colorado.jpg

Just like the Remote Area Medical clinic images a few weeks back provided a sobering counterpoint to the townhall cranks, Getty’s John Moore delivers a series offering a dose of reality to the “death panel” hysteria.

Moore visited the the Hospice of Saint John in Lakewood, Colorado, a non-profit that accepts terminally-ill patients regardless of their ability to pay — though most have Medicare.  Hospice administrators told Moore their services costs about a third the price of hospital care.

As a sensitive reply to the callous, two-dimensional and endless right-wing references to “pulling the plug,” Moore’s images capture the enormous cost — in painstaking effort, intense emotions, agonizing choices, and yes, financial burden surrounding the terminally ill. Most significantly, he frames the end of life as a process and a life stage — in contrast to its absurd framing as either a pre-paid ticket or somehow a determinative act.

In the photo, an RN comforts Ramond Garcia who was admitted to the hospice after suffering a debilitating stroke.

Pixtera slideshow: Caring for the Terminally Ill

(image: John Moore/Getty Images. August 20, 2009. Lakewood, Colorado)

  • Molly

    Having seen many parishoners at the end of life, I am eternally offended by the scare tactics of “death panels”. Fvck those who use this painful time in the lives of loved ones to score political points.

  • Tena

    This is what this country desperately needs and this is exactly what has been under attack – the recognition that every one of us dies and that perhaps it isn’t best to die in an ICU with doctors trying to bring you back when you are terminally ill. That’s what they did to my mother, even though I thought we had that covered. It’s not my idea of a good death and since we all die, I do believe there is such a thing as a good death. And I think secretly most people feel the same but are afraid to even think about it.
    America is the most death-averse culture – no one wants to talk about it reasonably or deal with it. I have friends who actively hid the fact of dying from their children which I think is obscene. We need the kind of end of life discussion that leads to this kind of care at the end of life instead of the way it is now – thousands upon hundreds of thousands of dollars spent trying to keep people alive another 5 minutes when they would die naturally if left alone.

  • http://www.innterressting.com Tomandlou

    I would never ask that anyone should have to make a decision on terminating a life ! I was forced to do it for my Mother at 87 lbs.Semi conscious with a broken hip and no hope.It haunts me to this day and I’m 72! I have a DNR.and believe me its a relief knowing none of my children will have to make that choice for me.These insenstative #$%&* That are scaring so many people well maybe I would’nt have a problem making it for them !

  • Tena

    I had to sign a release to let them take off my mother’s leg and the only thing I was sure of at the time was that if they did take it off and she lived, she would never forgive me.
    But of course, they carved her up like a salmon and then she died. Which I could have told them was going to happen. My long term health care plan is to be left alone when the time is getting there. I really have almost a horror of the idea of being poked and prodded when I’m dying. No thank you.

  • http://solarray.blogspot.com gmoke

    I’ve sat by a hospice bedside twice now as loved ones died. I don’t want to do it again. The hospice care I’ve experienced is deeply compassionate, human, and humane. The people who work with those at the end of life are special people who take the responsibility very seriously.
    The level of hysteria and unreality in American political discourse is a form of lethal stupidity. The Republicans and the insurance company PR firms can manufacture their scare propaganda without any fear that the million dollar media will contradict them or call them on their BS. I don’t blame the Reps and the PR people. I blame the overpaid idiots who like to pretend they are reporters and pundits. Their tune changes when real life invades their perfumed quarters.

  • http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1915835,00.html yg

    sarah palin and the loony laurouchians keeps citing (and twisting it out of context) writings from dr. ezekiel emanuel (rahm’s brother) to support their claim that obama plans to form a death panel with the purpose of killing off the elderly and the infirmed.
    turns out ezekiel is not only OPPOSED to euthanasia, but his own sister suffers from cerebral palsy.
    “I couldn’t believe this was happening to me,” says Emanuel, who in addition to spending his career opposing euthanasia and working to increase the quality of care for dying patients is the brother of White House chief of staff Rahm Emanuel. “It is incredible how much one’s reputation can be besmirched and taken out of context.”
    http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1915835,00.html
    how many people with handicapped children or sick parents have bought into rightwing smears and have been needlessly been terrorized? political terrorists like palin, bachmann and grassley have no conscience.

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p010537194843970b Hippocrates

    The “death panel” argument’s success speaks to the public’s immaturity in dealing with serious issues. Our youth-obsessed culture has, in favor of focus on childish frivolity, put off important conversations about myriad topics like race, our insensitivity to suffering, and our inability to contemplate our mortality. Perhaps a horrible economic downturn has a silver lining — eliminating the consumption culture would go a long way toward national maturation.

  • Sybil

    I am a physician–one of my former mentors used to say –”we need to make sure the things we are doing TO this patient are really doing things FOR this patient” (meaning the whole patient, not just the respiratory parameters on the ventilator). Often physicians feel like they have failed if they don’t continue to do “something”. Our culture here in the US is very interventional. Obviously the wonderful staff depicted in this photo essay are continuing to do many things FOR these patients. Stopping futile treatment and focusing on spirituality, family, and pleasurable experiences like music and massage are life affirming even when death is inevitable.

  • http://thefamilyplot.wordpress.com/ Gail Rubin

    My father-in-law died this year in April, and even with advance medical directives in place, real life gets messy. Families need to be able to talk to each other as well as the doctors involved with a loved one’s care.
    I write a blog called The Family Plot: Funeral Planning for those Who Don’t Plan to Die. You can read my father-in-law’s story at http://thefamilyplot.wordpress.com/2009/08/19/death-panels-or-prudent-planning/. See how important it is to speak and listen with the head as well as the heart.

  • http://deathclubforcuties.blogspot.com Jerry

    Thanks for posting this. I hadn’t seen it until today.
    I’m going to post a brief summary and link at my blog for end of life care nurses, Death Club for Cuties.

  • http://www.yahoo.com Ellen

    As far as I am concerned ,hospice is the only way to “go”. There is dignity,compassion, individuality,family,and humanity. what a sharp contrast from the cold, sterile uncaring world of the hospital and the inhumane treatment of the money making machines they refer to as patients.We all need to support all these hospice havens that have the guts to really reach out and make a dynamic difference for those and their families and loved ones at the twilight of their life.