BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 24, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



August 16, 2009

New York Mag’s Selling (and Selling and Selling Out) of the President

NY Mag Obama.jpg

New York Magazine’s article about Obama’s “media blitzkrieg” (“The Message Is the Message”) is a lot smarter than the illustrations — unfortunately.

It not only speaks to the President’s practice — in the age of blogs, specialty presses, Facebook, Twitter, SMS, Flickr, and YouTube — of meeting and managing all these challenging delivery vehicles but to go beyond them to deliver deeper, longer and richer communications — particularly, lessons about values and responsibility — in what the article coins as the “post-sound bite long form.”

The problem, however, is that the the lead image above and the two other prominent illustrations (1, 2), in tandem with the Mag’s cover, not only contradict the points and the nuance of the article. In doing so, it actually ends up putting up in lights central memes used to trash Obama — specifically, that he’s hopelessly narcissistic and overexposed.

It’s that problem, plus the fact the comment thread had been largely hijacked by trolls, that led one reader, OBAMAHATERTELEPROMPTERPOINTS, to proclaim:

Here are the latest Obama Hater teleprompter talking points:

1. Obama is the first narcissistic president. The Bushies and Ronnie Rayguns were never narcissistic. No other president ever had a large ego and a need to be in the spotlight. They all sought public office, culminating in the presidency, because they are shy, retiring, modest types.

2. Obama was not only born in Kenya. He was transported there from an alien spacecraft. Obama is ET, the Brother From Another Planet. It’s not just the Socialists, it’s the Martians who are using him to enslave the White population of the planet.

3. Obama’s multitasking, bouncing from one message to another, has nothing to do with the plate of woe and ineptitude he was served up by the previous administration. It is merely a consequence of his ADD. It is not his sense of duty and perseverance. It is a character flaw, a disease.

4. Obama doesn’t work, he delegates. That he is in constant, spinning motion, handling a multitude of issues, is not a sign of work. Little Bushie was the real worker: our First Vacationer, who spent over one third of his administration either at Crawdad or Camp David. Why can’t Obama be more like him?

5. Obama has the media in his pocket. The media are a bunch of blushing schoolgirls when exposed to his charm. (Somehow Glenn Dreck, Sean Insanity, Lush Lumbago, Bilious O’Rudely and numerous other FoxNews hate spewers seem immune.)

6. Obama has charmed the media. He is a “salesman”. The Bush/Cheney approach was much better: choke the media. Deny access. Intimidate. Snarl.

7. Obama is “Big Brother”. His image is everywhere, watching us. On the other hand, Little Bushie’s Gonzalez-enabled wiretaps of private communications is not “Big Brother”, because Republicans justify it as a security measure.

8. Obama is black (OK, half black) and surrounded by Jews. need I say more? Where are the REAL Americans?

9. Be afraid. Be very afraid.

Falling victim to their own “carpet Obaming,” it’s NY Mag that missed the teachable moment.
(Revised for logic. 8/16/09. 9:40 am PST)


(Photo-illustration by James Porto. Photos: From left to right: Haraz N. Ghanbari/AP; Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP; Kristoffer Tripplaar/Sipa Press; Lawrence Jackson/Landov; Joshua Roberts/UPI/Landov; Courtesy of the White House; Lauren Victoria Burke/Courtesy of ABC News)

  • Tena

    I think you got it – you covered the field.
    It’s machine guns clips full of crazy out there right now.

  • bystander

    I preferred your original notes. As I am remembering them… selling and selling out and is smarter than it looks
    The narrative and the visuals work at such cross purposes you’d wonder if they weren’t constructed for two different audiences.

  • dada

    Re the neg commenters: I can understand blitzing a story like this or articles on policy or Obama’s administration, but what I’m finding really intriguing (and a bit scary) is that they also go to light-hearted stories about events at the White House or the Obama family or Michelle’s wardrobe (etc) and troll there. I suppose it’s good that they do because it’s made more clear they ain’t interested in communicating anything more than hatred.
    Re NY Mag’s story & cover: It would be interesting to know about the editorial meetings that came up with this disconnect.

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p0120a4fd35ea970b goldenheart888.wordpress.com

    The Smelling and Smelling and Smelling of the Obamanation:
    http://alligatorfarm.wordpress.com/2009/08/17/smelling-obamanation-media/
    Chase Hunter

  • yg

    did you hear obama’s conference call from yesterday? media are playing soundbites from it:
    WASHINGTON (CNN) — President Obama appealed Wednesday to faith-based groups to help garner support for his plan to overhaul the nation’s health care system.
    “I need you to knock on doors, talk to neighbors, spread the facts and speak the truth,” he told religious leaders and reporters on a conference call that was streamed over the Web at faithforhealth.org.
    “This debate over health care goes to the heart of who we are as a people,” he said. “I believe that nobody in America should be denied basic health care because he or she lacks health insurance.”
    Some 140,000 people participated in the call, the coalition of more than 30 faith-based groups that organized the event said in a written statement.
    Obama urged the listeners to reject misinformation about his plans, noting, “There are some folks out there who are, frankly, bearing false witness.”
    He referred to some assertions as “ludicrous,” and cited as an example rumors that the government is planning to set up “death panels” to determine the fate of the nation’s elderly.
    “That is just an extraordinary lie,” he said, adding that it was based on a provision in the House legislation that would allow Medicare to reimburse someone who voluntarily sought counseling on how to set up a living will for the end of life.
    “It gives an option that people who can afford fancy lawyers already experience,” the Harvard-trained lawyer said.
    In addition, the plan does not provide health insurance to illegal aliens, it does not represent a government takeover of health care and it would not lead to government funding of abortion, he said.
    “These are all fabrications that have been put out there in order to discourage people from meeting what I consider to be a core ethical and moral obligation: that is, that we look out for one another; that is, I am my brother’s keeper, I am my sister’s keeper. And in the wealthiest nation in the world right now we are neglecting to live up to that call.”
    Obama, who took no questions, said the opposition was no surprise. “Throughout history, whenever we have sought to change this country for the better, there have always been those who wanted to preserve the status quo,” he said. “These always boil down to a contest between hope and fear.”
    Prior to the call, Obama’s director of domestic policy, Melody Barnes, said the president still believes that including a public option is the best way to achieve low-cost, affordable health care.
    The public option has been a sticking point among some Republicans, who consider it to be the camel’s nose under the tent of government-run health care.
    But, she added, “he also said he’s open to other ideas.”

    obama sounded stronger, more confidant and more comfortable off camera. he should do more of these.

  • http://www.cnn.com/2009/POLITICS/08/19/obama.health.care/index.html yg

    from the above article:
    “It gives an option that people who can afford fancy lawyers already experience,” the Harvard-trained lawyer said.
    this is how LBJ managed to get headstart passed. republicans at the time fearmongered the proposal was an evil, socialistic, communistic, big government plot to take small children and “indoctrinate” them. headstart? an evil plot? lol
    the more things change, the more things stay the same.
    LBJ argued rich people put their kids in daycare. working people should have the same option. with that, headstart was born.
    remember that next time. when it’s good enough for the wealthy, that’s just dandy. but only when the option is made available for the working class – then suddenly, a perfectly commonsense proposal morphes into something, oooooooh, eeeeevvilllllllll. run for your lives!

  • http://andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com/the_daily_dish/2009/08/chart-of-the-day-9.html yg

    specifically, that he’s hopelessly narcissistic and overexposed.
    what the critics are saying is that it’s obama’s fault that he’s popular. but why should he held responsible for other people’s reactions?
    via ben smith:

    this must drive the right crazy.

  • yg

    1. Obama is the first narcissistic president. The Bushies and Ronnie Rayguns were never narcissistic. No other president ever had a large ego and a need to be in the spotlight. They all sought public office, culminating in the presidency, because they are shy, retiring, modest types.
    2. Obama was not only born in Kenya. He was transported there from an alien spacecraft. Obama is ET, the Brother From Another Planet. It’s not just the Socialists, it’s the Martians who are using him to enslave the White population of the planet.
    7. Obama is “Big Brother”. His image is everywhere, watching us. On the other hand, Little Bushie’s Gonzalez-enabled wiretaps of private communications is not “Big Brother”, because Republicans justify it as a security measure.

    it’s hard to tell at first blush with all the crazies running around, but i call spoof.
    - “ronnie rayguns”? true conservos don’t mangle the name of their great leader.
    - martians? lol
    - in number 7, he refers to republicans as if he wasn’t one. and republican don’t refer to bush as little.

  • Louis Vuitton Shop

    We entered the dining hall. Louis Vuitton OutletBranca wore black shoes, chinos, a collared white shirt with three buttons.Chanel Purse I had not seen the pitcherBurberry Handbags since the 2010 memorial service  for Bobby Thomson, the batter Hermeswho had felled him. Gucci Shoes Thomson had been the quieter Louis Vuitton of the two — wholesale handbags a Glaswegian, a Protestant, Coach Factory a tenor, and Branca a New Yorker Coach Outlet Online, a Roman Catholic, a bass.Hermes Bags Branca folded his bare arms Coach Outlet and looked out onto the golf course.Burberry I asked if he had mentioned Wholesale Purses to anyone the reason for our Chanel Handbags lunch — the second revelation Louis Vuitton I had recently told him.Coach Outlet  He said he had told Louis Vuitton Outlet his wife, Ann. I passed the question to Gucci Michael Miller, a close friend Coach Factory Outlet and a professor of Coach Outlet Jewish history in Budapest.Louis Vuitton He contacted a Hungarian Jewish Coach Outlet Online genealogy group. And now,Coach Outlet at the country club where Coach FactoryBranca has lived since 1977,Coach Online Outlet I laid before him the records Chanel Handbags that Miller and the group had found.Coach Outlet Store OnlineThe 1884 marriage of Coach PursesIgnatz Berger and Antonia GipszCoach Factory, a ceremony at which Jakob Friedman,Gucci Outlet a rabbi in Sandorf, had officiated.Prada Outlet The births of the couple’s Coach Outlet Online eight children over the next 12 years: Kati, Coach Pursesthe eldest, and Miksa, SandorChanel Purses, Irma, Fanni, Sandor, Moricz and JozsefCoach Bags. (The first Sandor died as a toddler.) The mohels and sandeks who performed each bris Louis Vuitton Shop and held each boy during the circumcisions.