BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 24, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



August 26, 2009

Kennedy’s Passing: Change In Health Care Calculus, Or Same-Old, Same-Old?

gallery-tedkennedydies16.jpg

Of course, the ’sphere is awash in Teddy images right now, the day after his passing. I found this one, however — from TPM’s memorial slide show — particularly relevant.   

Going forward, the preeminent question is: what impact can and will Kennedy’s passing have on the health care reform process? Given the intense experience of fraternity in the Senate, Kennedy’s lifelong commitment to the issue, and his championing of a progressive way forward, can we expect a different emotional calculus now in the Congress, one which lifts members above the pettiness — a quality Biden movingly (and perhaps even strategically) articulated that Kennedy transcended?

…Or, is the status quo so great and the Democratic will so compromised that the trajectory of the past few weeks will remain largely unaffected and the “call” in Kennedy’s passing will be largely frittered away, his legacy mostly relegated to the media undertakers locked-and-loaded for a retrospective and funeral bonanza?

What’s telling about this Senate hearing room photo is that Kennedy, angled off as he is, represents the inflection point. The main tension, with the quasi-Democrat Lieberman in the middle and the chameleon-like, terminally unpredictable and even occasional humanist McCain center-right, is whether the conscience and echoing presence of Kennedy will somehow shine through these men or merely bounce off.

(image: unattributed. 2008. WDCPix.com via TPM)

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p00e5523476cc8834 DennisQ

    Is that a bad picture of McCain? I think he looks really unattractive, but I can’t figure out why. Ordinarily a smile improves one’s looks, but there’s something creepy about McCain’s face, and indeed, about Lieberman’s face as well. Maybe it’s that I’ve grown to despise both of them.
    No, I don’t think I would be smiling in John McCain’s company.

  • jtfromBC

    i observe
    a warrior a weasel and a ‘war hero’
    where photo op similes dominate 2-1
    where money will trump morality 2-1
    where charity substitutes for social justice 2-1
    where liberal compassion loses to ‘compassionate conservatives’ 2-1
    i assume it will be the same-old same-old
    and will not be listening to the weasel or the ‘war hero’

  • http://leftistmoon.wordpress.com Wordsmith

    What jt said….

  • Molly

    If I were in Congress, I’d use Ted’s life work for all it was worth. Which is a lot to a lot of people, actually.

  • yg

    one of the reasons, i think, obama pushed for passage of the bill before august recess was not only because he knew opposition would have a chance to rev up against it, but because he wanted kennedy to see the realization of his life’s work while he was still alive.
    let’s look at the timeline. obama gave a town hall with max baucus on august 14. eleven days later, kennedy dies. seeing obama being supportive and speaking positively of baucus while knowing baucus was the one responsible for holding the bill up in committee – must have been a kick in the gut for ted. couple that with seeing obama’s initial coyness that signalled a willingness to give up on the public option, must have been so disappointing.
    somebody demoralized like that is more likely to give up on his will to live. ted put so much on the line and stuck his head out to come out in support for obama. how did obama return the favor? he stabbed him in the back by supporting the man who was trying to kill kennedy’s bill. yes, ted had cancer but i think this betrayal was also a factor in his death.
    surely obama could have done more to twist baucus’ arm to get him to release the bill. now it’s too late. reforms eventually will get passed, but because of obama’s cowardly caution in failing to draw a line in the sand and being overly deliberative, ted was denied a chance to see it done.