BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Monday, February 13, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



July 21, 2009

Bagram: Nobody Here But Us Humanitarians

(Note: One image somewhat graphic)


One of the hallmarks of the Iraq and Afghanistan campaigns has been the absurd disconnect between what the military showcases for the visual media as compared to what otherwise is happening “on the ground.”

Writes DDay yesterday:

From the did you know file, did you know that the United States continues to operate, and assert the legality of operating, a detention facility that indefinitely locks up suspects without charging them? No, not Guantanamo, which the President has vowed to close. I’m talking about Bagram Air Force Base in Afghanistan, which is not merely a POW facility but which ships in terror suspects from all over the world and confines them in a legal black hole. There is little knowledge of this or outcry about it in the United States, but the prisoners themselves have begun acts of civil disobedience. (More.)

According to a piece in yesterday’s Washington Independent, the dismissal of a Bagram prisoner’s habeus corpus petition at the end of June has led to mass upheaval on the part of the prisoners:

Reports today that the U.S. military is calling for an overhaul of the Bagram prison in Afghanistan follow weeks of little-reported protests by prisoners there, who since July 1 have refused to leave their cells or participate in video-phone calls with family members, all to protest their indefinite detention, says the International Committee of the Red Cross, which informed families of the protests. Prisoners are reportedly refusing even to meet with the ICRC.

If you track the news photos from Bagram over the past month at a newswire site like Daylife, however, what you get, over the past month, is a smattering of photos of soldiers remains being shipped to the U.S.; the treatment of wounded soldiers at the Bagram hospital; a U.S. change-of-command ceremony at the air base: a few images showing soldiers removing land mines; and military ceremonies marking Memorial Day.

Of the images, though, impossible to miss are the nineteen pictures or so dealing with eight-year-old Razia, who — according to the captions:

…was evacuated to the hospital in May after she was severely burned when a white phosphorus round hit her home in the Tagab Valley, killing two of her sisters during fighting between French troops and Taliban militants.

Although Razia’s father does appear in a couple of pictures, it’s great to know she has otherwise bonded with American military personnel (no hard feelings), received the best health care money can buy, and has even learned a few of our games. …All that, while events on the POW-side proceed along stealthily the way things at black sights typically do.

(images: Rafiq Maqbool/A.P. June 2009. For captions, see link below slide show)

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p00e5523476cc8834 DennisQ

    Americans love to identify themselves with the medical staff who seem to have become attached to this little girl. And for once, we’re not the ones who permanently scarred her – this time, it was the French. We feel good about ourselves without a twinge of guilt.
    When the medical staff rotates back to the States, this child may bond with their replacements … or she may not. By then the ward may have filled up with other, even more pathetic victims. This little girl may experience renewed heartbreak when the people she’s come to love are gone.

  • Tena

    It’s more than just a disconnect by now – it’s psychotic. There are two distinct realites vying for first place here – the America that exists in so many Americans’ minds – the one where we’re all humanitarians and exceptional and care deeply about people like Raiza and will claim it isn’t our fault -
    And the other America, the one that has been in the dark for so long and now there’s some light on it and Americans refuse to acknowledge that reality – the Bagram reality. The black sites. The reality that we did this to this little girl. And if we hadn’t there wouldn’t be any need for all the rest, which is just guilt-assuaging on a national basis and delusional to the point of schizophrenic.

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p00e5523476cc8834 DennisQ

    Did the aristocrats who signed the Declaration of Independence really believe what they were signing? Jefferson, who actually wrote the Declaration, was himself a slave owner.
    The contradiction in American attitudes has been there from the beginning. Contradictions abound! In support of national self-determination, we invade other countries and impose our political standards on them. Saddam may have been democratic enough for the Iraqis, but by God, he wasn’t democratic enough for us!
    Similarly, we love little Razia so much we’re prepared to inflict similar pain on hundreds of other Afghan children. They deserve better than the government they’ve got, and we’re going to see that they get it!

  • http://reciprocity-failure.blogspot.com Stan B.

    And we will continue to delude ourselves till the bitter end…

  • LL

    why does Theresianstadt come to mind?
    Probably because it’s a perfectly logical stretch, under these circumstances.