BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Monday, February 13, 2012
May 2, 2009

The Texas Pioneer Adventure Is Closed

©NinaBerman-Iraq-Refugee.jpg

click for full size

The Iraqi refugee dips her head. Her child — in the Winnie the Pooh hat — clutches to her. The trees block a wide marine vista. The Texas flag doubles back on itself. The wagon ride is that way. The sign on the chain reads: “The Texas Pioneer Adventure is closed.”

This photo, taken by contributer Nina Berman, shows an Iraqi immigrant on a group visit, with other Iraqi women, to a park and arboretum in Texas. It does not specifically show discouragement or exclusion. It does not specifically demonstrate Iraqi refugees coming to the U.S. in a pioneering spirit and being effectively denied access to our culture, history and pastimes.

Still, given the dire circumstances Iraqi immigrants are facing here in the U.S., this is effectively true — the image, in fact, juxtaposing this hokey monument to the pioneer spirit with an Iraqi struggling with the recession, local indifference and limited if any support from the U.S. to help establish herself “in the homeland.”

I recommend you go over Alternet to read Nina’s report on Iraqi refugees in Dallas, and to see her accompanying slide show.

(image: Nina Berman, Dallas, TX. 2009)

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p00e5523476cc8834 DennisQ

    The West was settled by people who were displaced from the crowded slums of Eastern cities. By legend they were people with what has been called the Pioneer spirit, but the reality might have been otherwise. They went West only because they couldn’t stay where they were; there was no place for them.
    The picture closes the circle somewhat. We see a latter-day “pioneer” confronting the myths surrounding her predecessors. Wagon rides for family amusement, indeed. I wonder what the actual survival rate was for the early settlers. Traveling cross country in a covered wagon must have been an ordeal, which they would certainly not have undertaken except in extremis. Westward ho, the wagons!

  • http://www.eatbees.com/blog/ eatbees

    Is a picture still worth a thousand words in today’s economy? This one needs a hell of a lot of explaining to get its message across.