BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 24, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



April 2, 2009

Gee!

610x-17.jpg

By next summit, we’ll surely see a less effusive, even “Golly, gee!” Obama. Attending his first such get together, however, and certainly being confident and unselfconscious enough to let his excitement show through, history will record many shots such as this one, of the President just plain “stoked,” as people used to say.

At the same time, chumming with Burlusconi, the crooked media mogul-turned-PM (twice over) and Putin’s lightweight tool Medvedev, this moment could be analagous to the experience where, coming across a forgotten picture taken years before in your first week at a new school, your reaction is: “what was I doing it up with those guys for?”

(Reuters/Pool. caption:U.S President Barack Obama (L) laughs with Italy’s Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi (C) and Russia’s President Dmitry Medvedev as they pose for a family photograph at the G20 summit at the ExCel centre, in east London April 2, 2009. World leaders are set to declare an end to unfettered capitalism at a G20 summit on Thursday after France and Germany demanded they act fast on promises to prevent a repeat of the worst economic crisis since the 1930s.)

« Prev

  • z0rs

    I am italian and living in italy, and knowing the director and first actor of this picture, I feel disgusted by the picture itself. You can see the totally exaggerated smile (contagious) of the little dictator, he has been craving for such a picture since months, for self legitimation on the international arena, for local use. It is not casual that he seems to be the tallest one of the three. And this is one of those exceptional occasions where even Obama’s smile doesn’t look natural, it’s forced, barely anyone with some good common sense can stand the guy and it shows.
    Also notice the asimmetry in Berlusconi’s face, that’s not causal too, his smile is never simmetric and i believe it shows the man inside, a psychologic radiography, so unbalancedly fake and without limits, can’t control itself.
    Despite the smile that seems to level the characters, it’s very very different apples the ones in the basket.
    Italy has been and is being looted more than ever, and having to see this kind of trash too.. it’s disgusting.

  • yg

    oh, obama. tsk, tsk, he looks too eager appease. and the thumbs up is so cliche. used to irritate me when hrc would overdose doing this on stage at rallies. at least he isn’t doing the simulataneous thumbs up and finger pointing with the other hand, a la buddy christ:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddy_Christ
    how many borderline bigoted quips have berlusconi leveled at obama? now he’s desperate to be seen with him. what’s silvio’s approval ratings?
    maybe obama’s feeling loopy from cold medication.
    on the other hand, perhaps the show of unity will end up being productive somehow.
    is there a wider frame of this shot?

  • http://jprestonian.blogspot.com/2009/01/breathe-little-easier.html#links yg

    photoshopped, but i liked this gesture honoring his hawaiian roots.
    http://jprestonian.blogspot.com/2009/01/breathe-little-easier.html#links

  • mon_oeil

    I am taken aback as well by Obama’s overeagerness to join the club. Medvedev has now called him his “new comrade”. I too agree that Berlusconi has been itching to meet Obama to really see how tanned he is compared to himself. To add to the list of G20 gestures, Obama interrupts Lula, to shake his hand and say, “Love this guy. He’s the most popular politican on earth. It’s because of his good looks.” By his reaction it did not appear that Lula thoroughly understood as the comment was being translated. What was that about, hmmm!

  • charlie

    What makes you think that picture is photoshopped? I saw him do that live on TV many times during the parade.

  • yg

    really? coolness. a parade where?
    ‘cuz when you zoom in, you can see where the tip of his pinkie finger is lighter than the rest of his hand.

  • funkalunatic
  • http://jprestonian.blogspot.com/ Jeffraham Prestonian

    I pulled that photo from one of the news sites, so I suspect it was NOT Photoshopped. I believe this was from the Grant Park appearance on election night.
    .

  • Fiorentina

    Zors, you said it. My husband is Italian and we are constantly disgusted and ashamed by Berlusconi’s behavior. He’s been *dying* to be in a photo with Obama, and he must have been scrambling to get on the top tier for the photo op. I don’t think Obama’s smile is real; he looks very stiff and uncomfortable. God only knows what Berlusconi said to him, but I bet you he goes back to Italy and crows about his new BFF.

  • z0rs

    Silvio’s ratings are horribly high (in Italy of course) since he controls over 90% of the media and constantly manipulates it. He wouldn’t need this kind of stuff for the ratings, but he does for his own giant ego.

  • z0rs

    Afterwards he declared:
    - he joked a lot with Obama.
    - but he’s young and he still has a lot to learn from us elders.
    - he’s hot and is great in human relationships.
    - he is to be credited the good relationship between U.S.A. and Russia.
    Fits perfectly and helps understand the picture.

  • http://justbetweenstrangers.blogspot.com/ acm

    funny that this shot has Obama with the thumbs-up — the version I saw first had *Berlusconi* with the thumbs-up sign. equally goofy and odd.

  • yg

    doesn’t it look like berlusconi pulled obama into his sphere with his right hand?

  • yg

    thank you, zors, for the follow up after report.

  • z0rs

    I am afraid I wrote it unclearly, I will correct here:
    Berlusconi said:
    Obama is hot (best translation for what he said) and is great in human relationships.
    I (Berlusconi) am to be credited for the good relationship between U.S.A. and Russia.
    The latter sentence is plain laughable, but it gets less funny since he actually says that.

  • yg

    i want to see that version.

  • mon_oeil

    In contrast to funkalunatic’s take on the Yalta Conference photo op, I find Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin, much more dignified, much more a representation of heads of state at a crucial moment in history. Perhaps yg is correct, that Berlusconi pulled Obama into the picture. But did he have to indulge him in this frat boy display that appears so unpresidential. I imagine Medvedev got a good scolding from Putin! When looking at Obama’s photo op with other heads of state: Merkel, Hu Jintao, King Abdullah bin Abdul Aziz Al Saud, among others, one sees a much more formal encounter, as it should be, for instance, the very ceremonial exchange with Sarkozy, which ironically one could very much see the latter in this type of funfest with the guys. Almost too formal–one may note that Obama did not exchange the customary bises with Carla Bruni, as Sarkozy did with Michelle.

  • http://ochairball.blogspot.com/2009/04/thumbs-up-obama-berlusconi-medvedev.html yg
  • http://www.agrippinaminor.com/wp/ Wayne Dickson

    Wait a minute! Why did you crop out the Chinese guy? To my mind your picture creates a significantly different impression than the uncropped version.
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/04/02/g-20-leaders-goof-around_n_182307.html