BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 24, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



February 12, 2009

Infantilizing Obama

Obama-Baby-Mother-Jones.jpg

Oh, baby.

In a far cry from any honeymoon, it seems Washington has been testing Obama from minute one (including the broader Democratic and Republican left and right; the blogosphere; Pelosi and Reid; the Congressional GOP; and particularly the press — in leaning on Obama to submit to questions in his informal first visit to the WH press room, for example, or to explain, in his first question in his first press conference, whether he wasn’t going overboard in his warnings about the financial crisis.)

One form of that testing — beautifully exemplified by the expression of infantilization above — has been to subtlety question if Obama is too young or inexperienced for the job. (I could see how various people — a Maureen Dowd immediately comes to mind — would have already been planting seeds of doubt by referring to the new president as a boy if his race didn’t completely negate going there.)

Besides the obvious analogy in the drawing — MJ appropriating the News Years imagery to put Obama in a diaper — we see Obama looking back as if second-guessing himself, not knowing what to do, and/or wondering how he got himself into this.

That pole might have a more phallic interpretation also — like our baby’s got a lot to balance there, but more than he knows what to do with.

(edited: 2:14 pm.)

(illustration: Dale Stephanos with a hat tip to The Saturday Evening Post)

  • https://w1.buysub.com/pubs/N3/GQM/images/obama_he.gif yg

    the vanity fair article about the obama crew members had this image on the side as an offer.
    https://w1.buysub.com/pubs/N3/GQM/images/obama_he.gif
    it came out in november but i had missed seeing it. it caught my eye because i had not yet seen a portrait before that made obama look older than he was. his inherent self-confidence was reassuring to see.
    the GQ cover was such a contrast to the vanity fair cover where, much like this MJ portrait, they made obama look plagued with doubt and worry.
    http://www.vanityfair.com/images/magazine/2009/03/0903VFcover-242px.jpg
    did the stimulus brouhaha expose obama as too inexperienced? ryan lizza had a good line: Obama has the misfortune of starting his Presidency with the one piece of legislation guaranteed to cause the fiercest partisan combat.
    naom scheiber thinks there’s method to the madness:
    http://blogs.tnr.com/tnr/blogs/the_plank/archive/2009/02/10/obama-s-stimulus-rope-a-dope.aspx

  • http://www.errolmorris.com/content/interview/stopsmiling0306.html yg
  • http://someoldguy.wordpress.com/ Phil Sheehan

    That pole isn’t for balance — it’s too short, to rigid. It looks more like the kind of staff used in martial arts. Obama could be looking at an opponent who’s about to get whacked in the knee. (Not what the artist intended, maybe, but again, that ain’t a wire-walker’s balance pole in his hands.)

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p010536b2fa33970c Lightkeeper

    Or he might just be walking away from the left and wondering wtf they’re giving him that look.

  • http://dowdreport.blogspot.com Mo MoDo

    Maureen Dowd called Tim Geithner a puberty afflicted boy today.

  • Alan

    The expression on Obama’s face reads like fear and uncertainty, to me, but I don’t read the man that way. Obama’s in far over his head, but ANYONE else who had his job right now would be, as well. To me, the president is smart, serious and courageous. The idea of picturing him walking a tightrope is appropriate enough, and even picturing him as a baby is acceptable to me, because he is young and short on CEO experience. But making him look fearful is a cheap shot, because I haven’t seen him look that way.
    Aside from that, I don’t think the art work is good. What’s up with that body? It looks like one of those latex sumo wrestler costumes.

  • http://profile.typepad.com/boxcar boxcar

    With the orange “sun” in the back and the angles of the tight-rope bend, the angle of the balance rod and obama’s shape take on an japanese character shape.
    Certainly reads to me as a “couching tiger” scene; with obama’s look of guile.
    of course the caption under cuts all that.
    peace
    boxcar

  • http://notmytribe.com Eric -NotMyTribe

    I can’t help but see his stick as a hunting spear, and baby Obama as Elmer Fudd as a loin-clothed pygmy. But I’m unsure what subversion is meant by the Japanese sun.

  • http://profile.typepad.com/vcInCA vcInCA

    i see a particular prominence on his ears, ala bush & the chimp pics, and ala quail (remember him?). but that’s just a minor thing.
    my main point is that i think you could also (but i’m not sure if MJ intended this) read the infant pic as evoking the fact that he was just elected, that he is in a rapidly growing/learning stage, infantile, in some sense, esp. given that he didn’t just pull cabinet members & advisors who have been there before, know how it runs, etc. in that sense, i see the cover as less hostile towards him, and instead as just acknowledging how much experience he actually HAS in the white house or how ‘lifers’ in DC may be seeing him. if you take that one step further, and look at the byline below him, in conjunction w/ his facial expression, i see it as them saying he is having to grow up faster than one should, but despite his baby fat, his facial expression shows that he’s got a brain, and a goal, is a very determined child. and highly determined 2 year olds have quite power over adults, in my experience, simply b/c they do not acknowledge the ‘rules’ or what’s ‘acceptable’-they plough through & force you to do it their way. given that possible reading, i rather like this cover, actually. its fairly hopeful, but cynical towards those who see him in the ‘infancy’ of his presidency & his ‘determination,’ if you will. does anyone else see this, or am i a tribe of 1 here?

  • bystander

    About that Japanese sun

    So far the Obama administration’s response to the economic crisis is all too reminiscent of Japan in the 1990s: a fiscal expansion large enough to avert the worst, but not enough to kick-start recovery; support for the banking system, but a reluctance to force banks to face up to their losses. Paul Krugman

  • MS

    Yuchh – our sad ‘leftie’ journalism that manages to insult the new president before even giving him a chance to achieve anything.

  • http://www.errolmorris.com/content/interview/stopsmiling0306.html yg