BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Monday, February 13, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



February 27, 2009

First Returns On Obama, C.I.C.

Obama Lejeune 1.jpg

Obama Lejeune 5.jpg

Obama Lejeune 4.jpg  

Looking at the first newswire photos of Obama as C.I.C. (in front of a large audience of soldiers at Camp Lejeune), the question, from a media standpoint, is: how well did he wear?

My sense is that Obama’s decision to lengthen the leave-taking from Iraq, and to keep more troops there than expected (at least, by Pelosi and the left) has a lot to do with earning/buying credibility with the military — and the hawks. What kind of immediate return does Obama earn, however, playing to the military and militarism?

These newswire shots offer three potential answers — to be determined today and tomorrow by photo editors who, as usual, are partly-channeling and partly-determining the general consensus.

Do we get more of the smallest “look at me” Obama almost lost in a sea of charges; do we get a central, but undefined Obama, the jury subject of an in-part wary, worried, curious and “show me” service; or do we get Obama clearly up-front, focused and in-command, the scale of the forces and mission simply background to how he’s putting his hand to it?

Of course, we’ll get visual media’s stamp on it almost right away.

(Update: Looks like the NYT took “the jury route” judging by the first picture in their Lejeune article)

  • http://msm.grumpybumpers.com/ mcc

    I just find it interesting that this plan was announced in the style of a friday newsdump.

  • ptm

    There’s no women in these pictures. If GB was doing this there would be a gaggle of mixed people racially and gender surrounding him with smiles of support. This is serious.

  • f

    These were Marines, not “Soldiers” as stated. There is a difference.

  • elfpix

    Not only is it serious, not only was his speech serious, but the people in the middle photo are, to a man, actually paying attention, with different qualities of skepticism, curiosity, thoughtfulness, doubtfulness in their faces. Were I an editor I would want to choose the image that revealed whether he got their attention, especially since he was on trial before them in this speech. “Can I respect this guy?” “How is this guy going to affect my life?” “Do I agree with what he’s telling me?” “What’s he sending me off to do?” “Is this guy really on my side?”
    President Obama has made a huge number of big speeches this week, it’s been kinda exhausting keeping up with it. These guys are no different from the other groups in that they’re testing, measuring the President against their calling and beliefs.
    A news editor should be interested in showing whether the President is turning out to be able to fulfill his role.
    I think the middle image shows that best.

  • http://profile.typepad.com/6p00e5523476cc8834 DennisQ

    These pictures show Obama’s willingness to go the extra mile to present his message. He could easily have written off the Marines at Camp Lejeune as out of reach, but he didn’t. Whether they’re disposed to like him or not, the Leathernecks are flattered that he came to them. In acknowledging that they matter, Obama softens up their resistance. He shows that he is concerned about them as human beings and as fellow Americans.
    Obama does this a lot – he goes to different constituencies and makes new friends. When he hosted right wing writers he didn’t expect to change their attitudes, and so far he hasn’t. But it’s possible that one of them, remembering his kindness, may actually cut him some slack. Whatever works with crusty old writers has got to work with Marines, who are younger and more open-minded.

  • http://www.fightingliberals.com Hubris Sonic

    hmmm…. awful lot of white faces, considering the Corps is 25% minority. hmmmm…

  • http://www.fightingliberals.com Hubris Sonic

    Also, the 2nd picture it almost looks like they are directing their glaring at someone behind the president…

  • charlie
  • http://www.fightingliberals.com the littlest gator

    NPR went with the out of focus Obama and skeptical troops shot.
    screen shot here

  • Progressive Mom

    What is startling to me is the lack of the “props” we’ve become used to under the Bush Administration: no huge American flags (no flag at all in the photos I’ve seen); no banner; no phalanx of dress-uniformed officers behind the President; no cardboard turkey in sight (remember that one?).
    What remains is a commander in chief, talking to his troops. It’s not a rally but rather a real address with real information.
    I think the seriousness of that sea of faces reflects our new reality, at home and abroad.

  • bkm242

    There was a mix of gender and ethnicity in the group of Marines placed behind the president while he spoke.

  • nightbird

    gee, these guys are young…

  • cenoxo

    The first American military action in BGWOT (Bush’s Global War On Terrorism) began in 2001 when America attacked and invaded Afghanistan because its Taliban rulers — America’s previous ‘friends’ and proxy allies against Soviet Russia’s 1979-1989 war in Afghanistan — refused to immediately turn over Osama Bin Laden.
    According to the Bush Administration, the purpose of our 2001 invasion was to bring the alleged perpetrator of the 9-11 attacks to justice, but that mission wasn’t accomplished either. We’re still looking for Osama Bin Laden over seven years later, but we really don’t know whether he’s dead or alive, or where he might be: any bets that American boots on the ground start looking for him in Pakistan?
    Now that we’ve segued into BGWOT (Barack’s Global War On Terrorism), Team Obama’s latest military goal is to support the weak, failed U.S.-backed Kabul government that was put into place after the Taliban were deposed. From the March 1, 2009 Jacksonville Daily News*, General to lead NC Marines off to Afghanistan:

    MARINE CORPS BASE CAMP LEJEUNE, N.C. (AP) — Brig. Gen. Lawrence Nicholson will assume command of the Marine unit headed to Afghanistan to stop a resurgent Taliban.
    Lt. Gen. Dennis J. Hejlik, commanding general of II Marine Expeditionary Force, will preside over Monday’s ceremony. The Camp Lejeune based Second Marine Expeditionary Brigade will deploy later this spring as part of a surge of forces to Afghanistan. The unit last deployed to Iraq in 2003.
    The 8,000 Marines are expected to go first, followed by an Army brigade, totaling about 4,000 troops, and 5,000 support forces. The United States has slightly more than 30,000 troops in the country now.

    All this in a fourth-world country that is larger and less developed than Iraq, and that has a smaller, less-educated, and more factious population. Can anyone say “mission creep”, “unintended consequences”, or “billion$ upon billion$”?
    Fortunately, now that Team Obama has authorized previously-forbidden photographs of flag-draped coffins as they return from BGWOT, the Repubs can no longer hide war ROI from the American public, and Dems (won’t) Fold Over Web Caskets.
    Government transparency may be improving, but how many of these Marines’ pictures will be in the papers again?

    Bring the troops home now, alive, before they’re FUBAR’d in an even worse mess.
    *Jacksonville, North Carolina — Camp LeJeune’s home town.

  • lytom

    I see cannon fodder made ready for Afghanistan. Mentality is the same obey, fight and kill. It is no longer Bushe’s war! It is Obama’s.