BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Saturday, February 04, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



January 31, 2009

For Shame

Obama Shameful.jpg

If it’s not the most complicated photo, that’s part of the point.

The most significant image of the week involved Obama — sitting with the newly confirmed treasury secretary — calling the media into the Oval Office to intentionally and pointedly shame Wall Street (using that exact word). Obama castigated the banking industry for irresponsibility in dishing out huge bonuses when the economy — in part, through its practices — is in the tank.

This is the shot the NYT ran, although it doesn’t coincide exactly with the shame comment (at around the 2:35 mark). Watching the video, I could imagine a sharper edge and smoother delivery from Obama if the administration wasn’t so “fresh out of the box” and “44″ felt a little more possessive of the office. But, that’s another thing the photos are for.

(image: Jim Young/Reuters. White House. January 29, 2009 via nyt.com)

  • Essjay

    I’d say he’s smooth enough. Sitting forward with elbows on his knees, speaking in a conversational manner (unlike Jr. who always spoke like an 8-year old reading the unfamiliar lines his handlers gave him).
    As to sharper…I’d like to see some FDR-style talk, like:
    We had to struggle with the old enemies of peace–business and financial monopoly, speculation, reckless banking, class antagonism, sectionalism, war profiteering…
    They are unanimous in their hate for me–and I welcome their hatred.
    I should like to have it said of my first Administration that in it the forces of selfishness and of lust for power met their match. I should like to have it said of my second Administration that in it these forces met their master.

  • cenoxo

    Timothy Geithner looks a little chagrined, like the kid who just got yelled at behind the Principal’s closed door.
    He ought to be — here’s the relevant bits of his bio at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York:

    • Ninth president and chief executive officer of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York on November 17, 2003
    • Vice chairman and a permanent member of the Federal Open Market Committee, the group responsible for formulating the nation’s monetary policy
    • 75th Secretary of the Treasury and the U.S. Senate confirmed him to the position on January 26, 2009
    • Joined the Department of Treasury in 1988
    • Worked in three administrations for five Secretaries of the Treasury
    • Under Secretary of the Treasury for International Affairs from 1999 to 2001
    • Director of the Policy Development and Review Department at the International Monetary Fund from 2001 until 2003
    • Worked for Kissinger Associates, Inc.
    • Graduated from Dartmouth College with a bachelor’s degree in government and Asian studies
    • Graduated from the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies with a master’s in International Economics and East Asian Studies
    • Studied Japanese and Chinese
    • Lived in East Africa, India, Thailand, China, and Japan
    • Chairman of the G-10’s Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems of the Bank for International Settlements
    • Member of the Council on Foreign Relations and the Group of Thirty

    With the best education that money could buy, international travel, over 20 years of on-the-job experience, and an impressive bipartisan Rolodex, the real shame is that Mr. Geithner and his colleagues — who were and are responsible for the sound construction of America’s monetary system — failed to see (not to mention avoid) the current worldwide economic crisis.
    This strains credulity: it was a financial 9-10 all over again, and all of the King’s smart guys didn’t make any difference. What else have they missed? If Obama insists upon retaining foxes to guard the henhouse, at least he could pick ovivores with a little better foresight.
    Compared to the trillions of ex nihilo TARP and Stimulus dollars about to be handed out, the bankers’ bailouts are trivial. Enron’s duplicity was a similar cookie jar caper, but at least Bush Administration prosecutors caught and convicted their executives.
    Is that an option today, or will today’s bad boy bankers feel so ashamed of themselves after Obama’s scolding that they’ll voluntarily return their ill-gotten gains?

  • cenoxo

    …the bankers’ bonuses are trivial…

  • thirdeye pushpin

    I also think that Geithner looks like a scolded child in this picture…so to whom is obama talking, the other kids Geithner was partying with….

  • robertdsc

    The President’s wedding ring and wristwatch jump out at me.

  • http://aol.com Sage

    I think Geithner has more of a cynical than chagrined look.

  • lytom

    It is starting to look like a dictate of a sharp one, the records don’t matter. Why put in charge crooks? Did FDR do that?

  • Our Paul

    Agree with robertdsc, that is one impressive looking watch. The question is what functions, other than keeping time, are built in… Obama after all is a technophile, that watch must have multiple functions!

  • cenoxo

    According to Barack Obama’s Watches (scroll about halfway down for details and images), it was a 46th birthday gift to then-candidate Obama from his Secret Service detail:


    The Secret Service chronograph given to Senator Obama by the Secret Service agents is a private label watch available only in the Secret Service employees’ store. The watch is manufactured for the Secret Service store by Jorg Gray, and appears in the Jorg Gray online catalog as the JGC6500 Chronograph. The chronograph is made in China, with a Japanese movement.

    Rumor has it that the watch also plays an appropriate security reminder:

    Every breath you take
    Every move you make
    Every bond you break
    Every step you take
    Ill be watching you
    Every single day
    Every word you say
    Every game you play
    Every night you stay
    Ill be watching you
    Oh, cant you see
    You belong to me
    How my poor heart aches
    With every step you take
    Every move you make
    Every vow you break
    Every smile you fake
    Every claim you stake
    I’ll be watching you

  • cenoxo

    Apparently, Obama’s scolding didn’t end with domestic Wall Street investment bankers.

    Treasury Secretary Geithner — reading from a prepared administration statement during his Senate Finance Committee confirmation hearing — also sent a message Far Eastward, but the recipients didn’t give too much currency to it.

    From the February 1, 2009 Times Online, Spat with China raises fears of a trade war:

    The new American Treasury secretary uses a Senate hearing room to accuse the Chinese of manipulating their currency, and the Chinese premier uses the Davos gathering of the moguls to accuse America of wrecking the world financial system. Not an auspicious beginning for Sino-American relations in the new era of the great believer in softly, softly diplomacy, Barack Obama.

    Tim Geithner has settled into his new job at the Treasury. It no longer matters that Geithner was the Fed’s man on Wall Street while the excesses and chicanery reached their peak. Or that he failed to pay his income taxes despite routine notifications from his former employer, the International Monetary Fund. Or that it was Geithner, along with his predecessor, Hank Paulson, who decided to let Lehman Brothers go under, bringing the financial system to the verge of collapse. That’s all behind him.

    What might be ahead is a trade war, triggered by Geithner when he told the Senate during his confirmation hearings that he believes China is “manipulating” its currency to maintain it at a low value so as to stimulate its exports. “Manipulate” is the word that upsets the Chinese, and imports are the things that most upset the trade unions and congressional Democrats who see them as destroying jobs in America – never mind the benefits to consumers.

    When China holds over $680,000,000,000 worth of U.S. Treasury notes, it is perhaps undiplomatic (and a little premature) to publicly accuse our largest foreign lender of manipulative financial dealings.

  • http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0192335/plotsummary yg

    it’s a shame alright. i’m not sure i buy what (i guess) passes for outrage.
    didn’t they see this coming? congress had a chance to legislatively spell out beforehand that none of the bail out money should be used for bonuses. an ounce of prevention… is worth billions?