BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Sunday, May 26, 2013

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement

October 23, 2008

Karl Escapes Citizen’s Arrest, Natch

Protesterrove

At first, I felt cheated by this particular shot … of Rove being accosted on stage on Tuesday at a mortgage bankers convention in San Francisco.  (It's the pic the NYT ran, and which nearly everyone else seemed to use.)  My first take had to do with the visual media fronting for Karl once more, avoiding the instant where — as the woman attempts to make a citizen's arrest –  he elbows her away.  (C&L has the video.)

But on second thought, it seems even more telling that Karl — clearly on the hot seat given the lunging protester; the glaring George Mitchell; and the likely fat speakers fee from a room full of America's darlings, the mortgage bankers — sits there staring straight ahead, like he's oblivious, wearing that sh-t-eating grin like it's still 2003.

By the way, don't you just love that tag line on the sign?  It reads: "Investing in communities."  I guess I'm also surprised nobody tried to execute a citizen's arrest on any of those mortgage brokers.

(image: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images.  October 21, 2008. San Francisco)

  • desertwind

    If that C&L video is the one from the SF tv station’s report, my fave part is where Karl tries to lecture George Mitchell against negative campaigns (by quoting a dumb “quip” that Kerry made) and Mitchell and the audience start laughing at him. Karl sounds so pathetic. He knows he’s old news.

  • Tina

    Sociopaths actually enjoy this kind of attention, so of course he’s smirking. A real arrest is what is called for.

  • shane

    I give that woman such huge props for the balls it took to do something we’d all LOVE to do.

  • http://www.jaxxattaxx.com/ black dog barking

    How is it these two men have equal standing before a convention of mortgage bankers? One is an attorney, former US Senator and Senate Majority Leader. The other didn’t complete college, spent most of his adult life engaged in gaming political elections.

  • Antonio

    One element that draws my attention is Senator Mitchell’s gaze. He’s not looking at the “action”, where my own eye first went upon seeing the photo and the video; he’s looking at Rove. It reminds me of two sports analogies:
    Consider how Madden watches a play during a particular down, and then comes back to help us see why the run covered 7 yards, or 2 or none.
    The other is my own ability to help my Little League players to see a play during a game. In Spanish there is a saying that the Devil knows more for being old than for being the Devil.
    The Senator “sees”.

  • mudkitty

    Rove looked like OJ when the 1st verdict came down.
    Sociopaths react with no emotion, or fake emotion.

  • http://home.comcast.net/~sfs73/images/WordyGrrrl.jpg MadameGonzo

    …Up on the stage walks a well-dressed woman, name as yet unknown. First she complained that there was no woman on the panel. Then she drew out handcuffs and tried to arrest Rove for treason.

    Hell hath no fury like a woman adorned ;-)

  • KansasKowboy

    Who is the man grappling with the woman? Roves bodyguard? If so he was a little slow on the job. I hope the next person who tries to make a citizens arrest of Rove better luck.

  • http://www.ninaberman.com NinaBerman

    When I saw the video it seemed to me that Rove was prepared for it as though he had imagined such a scenario taking place, even practiced for it, and felt satisfaction in his ability to remain composed, even bemused, swatting her off as though she was nothing more than a flea.

  • http://home.comcast.net/~sfs73/index.html MonsieurGonzo

    Up on the stage walks a well-dressed woman, name as yet unknown. First she complained that there was no woman on the panel. Then she drew out handcuffs and tried to arrest Rove for treason.

    ‘Anonymous’ …was a woman -Virginia Woolf

  • Gray Lensman

    “Karl and George couldn’t get a date to the dance.”

  • Johanna

    Oddly, if you didn’t know the security guard was hauling her off, the two of them look like a couple doing the tango. If the commenter thinks this is how OJ looked when the verdict came down, he has no memory of the occasion. It was the evening of yom kippur that year. OJ turned, sneered, and made strong eye contact with Kim Goldman. He was not trying to look composed, or look off in the distance like Rove is.

  • Taylor Menzo

    Typical, intolerant liberal idiot. “If you don’t agree with me I’m going to shut you up, using force if necessary”.
    Reminds me of Shrill Sheryl Crow trying to get in Rove’s face at the correspondents dinner and getting bitch slapped for her efforts.