Archives About Staff BagNews is dedicated to visual politics, media literacy and the analysis of news images.
September 13, 2008

September 11, 2008: What Is Still “Ground Zero”

This is the second year BAGnewsNotes has featured Alan Chin’s images of the 9/11 anniversary.  As opposed to our collaboration with Alan on subject matter more related to the “hard news” cycle, this work is much more personal and interpretive.  Given the “expansiveness” of the blog medium, we are happy to offer this work more in the spirit of a gallery exhibition.

The following is Alan’s statement about the images.  His work from last year’s anniversary is linked below.

Seven years after the attack on the World Trade Center, I returned again to the site as I have most years on the anniversary. I was struck with how, if you do not attend the official ceremonies with the families and the politicians, Lower Manhattan becomes a magnet for various groups and individuals touting their causes.

The 9/11 conspiracy theorists of both the far-right and far-left converge in a still small, but very visible presence, demonstrating and parading. Religious women raise their arms in prayer. Cops, both bored and dutiful, are necessarily out in force. Tourists peek under the fence to take photos of what is still “ground zero,” and vendors sell postcards, posters, T-shirts, depicting the event. Around them swirls the normal, everyday life of downtown, office and restaurant workers on breaks, commuters riding the PATH trains.

It is somehow moving, reflective, and exceptionally banal, all at the same time. The partisan politics are sharpened by this election year, as the Republicans attempt to lay “claim” or “ownership” over the legacy and symbolism. The fringe elements are entrenched in kitsch, as with the Chevrolet Corvettes painted with 9/11 imagery, or the bicyclist cruising down Broadway with a large American flag strapped to his seat. Yet for this photographer, and New Yorker, I still find it all to be a deeply personal and emotional experience: September 11, 2001 wasn’t, after all, political in the domestic sense. It was a catastrophic act of war, no more and no less, and its commemoration has devolved into idiosyncratic and extraordinary forms.

See Alan Chin’s 2007 9/11 anniversary images here.

(Images © Alan Chin.  New York. 2008.)

  • Angellight

    To me it seems somehow sadly symbolic that Ground zero is still a hole after 7 years. That we did not have the will and strength to make it something better, something positive, that we did not have the will to succeed. Nothing was done and nothing as long as we are under Republican rule will get done here in the United States. That is the symbol. That is what Ground Zero is teaching us.
    Sean Hannity Implodes on Obama Supporter! A look into the Character, meaness, ugliness and rudness of a GOP Operative.
    http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=NmcupSmgraw

  • martin

    There is something deeply truthful contained but not constrained in these images. I make no apology for using the word ‘deeply’ but would qualify truthful(ness) to be with a small and not a big ‘t’.
    Mr.Chin doesnt need praise from me. these pics tell a story that complements how the politicisation of the day and its resonant images in a way prevents closure. there is no possibility of ‘moving on’ from that day in september for many people. many of whom are american. And that makes me want to ask ‘why’?
    I dont see any semblance of a reconstruction accomplishment. outside of the many on the ground (sic) issues that have I am sure influenced decisions made – or not – (planning, victims relatives etc) it almost feels that that need to move on, almost like the labelled ‘war on terror’ itself is in a state of deferrment only a short, faultering step-down from denial.
    There is a sense in which that for me is not dissimilar from the current election process and omnipresent but under-spoken about thematics of racism.

Refresh Archives

Random Notes