BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Saturday, May 25, 2013

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement

September 1, 2008

Palin’s Place

Palin Baby Blackberry

Palin Feeding Baby

I've been trying to get a handle on the Sarah-Bristol-Trig story since the Kos piece came out alleging that Trig wasn't Sarah's baby.

Where I landed on this, even before this AM's news that Bristol is pregnant, is that Sarah Palin might have some problems with judgement.  One person who wrote me questioned what person (if the background is true) would insist on making a speech once her already high-risk labor started, then would take an extended flight home rather than going directly to a hospital.

It would be presumptuous, as well as sexist of me to suggest that a woman with a new baby, Down Syndrome or not, should or shouldn't be going back to work within a few days, or accepting the nomination and running for Vice President.  Given the fact a person with so little experience and qualification would so readily seek and accept a place on the ticket, however, and now factoring the news that Sarah Palin covered up her daughter's pregnancy (at least to the American public), you have to wonder who Palin really is.

In the admittedly subjective area of visual analysis, taking the stream of Palin pictures so far as the main source of data, a number of things suggest themselves — these two images from Megan McCain's blog distilling those concerns into single, discrete pictures.

In shot number one, Palin's use of the cell phone simultaneously with the Blackberry raises questions about her degree of organization, not to mention how much she's got her hands full.  Again, I did not select out the second shot as a singular example, but as the best representative of dozens and dozens of shots so far.  In this case, what the portrait raises for me is the degree of Palin's ambition.  What I'm drawn to is Sarah's affinity for the camera — Trig, even if inadvertently, serving as a prop for this photo shoot with People magazine.

(h/t: Larry)

(image: mccainblogette.com)

  • Karen

    Bag: A helpful source of pics of the Palin family (many of Bristol) at the Ohio gathering and on the bus was Meghan McCain’s blogette. It’s been down all morning and, I bet anything, is being scrubbed. Some of it is available via cache. I’m curious as to what they are hiding.

  • http://blogs.salon.com/0003935 Julia Grey

    The initial rumor-mongering at Kos was not a “Kos piece” (a term which can only rightly be applied to the Front Page stories in the large left column), it was in a diary/blog written by a fairly new member of that community, which is open to the general public.

  • charlie
  • Stefani

    Why do we never see pictures of Todd holding this baby? Why does she carry him around like this wherever she goes. Where is the father? It makes me feel like he is uninvolved. He has to be the man to raise this kid, and their kids, while she goes on her political tract. They had better show him stepping up to the plate soon or the world will see her as overworked and unqualified to do both the jobs of mother and vice-president.

  • mudkitty

    One thing for sure, she is using her children as props.

  • mudkitty

    One thing for sure, she is using her children as props.

  • sadja

    i believe the fact that they continue to state that “she kept the baby with down syndrome” and “Trig, the baby with down syndrome” is using that baby for a prop.

  • http://home.comcast.net/~sfs73/index.html MonsieurGonzo

    ref : “It would be presumptuous, as well as sexist of me. . .
    Well now, don’t let that stop you {grin}

    . . .for her 1949 treatise The Second Sex, a detailed analysis of women’s oppression and a foundational tract of contemporary feminism, Simone de Beauvoir sets out a “French Feminism” which prescribes a moral revolution. As an existentialist, she accepted Jean-Paul Sartre’s precept that existence precedes essence; hence “one is not born a woman, but becomes one“.

    ie., nous sommes celui qui nous feignons pour être => “we are that which we pretend to be”

    Her analysis focuses on the social construction of ‘Woman’ as ‘the Other’… This de Beauvoir identifies as fundamental to women’s oppression. She argues that women have historically been considered deviant and abnormal, and contends that even Mary Wollstonecraft considered men to be the ideal toward which women should aspire. De Beauvoir argues that for feminism to move forward, this attitude must be set aside.

    ( or, in your case, BAGman => “i am that which i presume my self not to be” :)
    THE END JUSTIFIES THE MEANS : “Just Win It, Baby!
    BAG NEWS NOTE: the Right will invent Big Brother; but it is the righteous Left who will use it, “rightly so”.

  • The BAG

    Karen, these shots came from that Blogette post.

  • bystander

    IMHO, Palin is GOP flame bait.

  • http://www.searchformajorplagge.com MichaelDG

    The question that the nation faces with Sarah Palin is “who is this person, what kind of values does she have, what kind of judgement and experience does she have”? For someone who professes to be a “family values” conservative, one has to wonder just how ambitious Governor Palin is when just four months after giving birth to a Down’s syndrome child and learning that your 17 year old daughter is pregnant, she decides to embark on a quest for the Vice Presidency. Is this the kind of family values decision making that the social conservatives are advocating? One also has to wonder about the judgement of someone with her lack of experience putting herself in the position of posibly being the commander in chief during a time of great danger and complexity. I think Sarah Palin is the most recklessly ambitious person I have ever seen- as is the person who decided to put her in this unstable situation.

  • jean

    http://www.andrewhalcro.com/shadow_governor A lot of talk that Todd Palin has his hands a lot more on the Governor’s job than we’d normally expect from a spouse. Were he a wife, we’d probably already be hearing the “Lady McBeth” line trotted out. “The stories started last year when Representative Ralph Samuels told me about going into a meeting, he thought would be private, with Governor Sarah Palin. Much to his surprise, Todd Palin was there and proceeded to sit through the entire meeting. “Other lawmakers have shared similar stories and were shocked at how inappropriate Todd’s presence was at meetings with the governor. Yesterday on the Dan Fagan Show, Representative Jay Ramras mentioned that Todd was working lawmakers offices during the ACES debate.”
    I think Stefani raises some interesting questions about ‘Todd’. In this quote from an Alaskan blog, he certainly has his nose into everything, which poses the question about his role in his wife’s elected position. This is different, I think than the normal spousal interest. HRC possibly played a similar role, but with less nefarious intentions. See the notes on the rest of Andrew Holcro’s blog regarding Mr Palin.
    The more I read the Alaskan blogs the more I worry about this WHOLE family being anywhere NEAR the White House.

  • BlakeIncarnate

    By now we all realize that Palin will withdraw. I’m wondering if it will be before the nomination or after? My personal guess is tommorrow.

  • funkalunatic

    FYI – Dennis Zaki (http://www.denniszaki.com/) of AlaskaReport.com is a good source of images for Palin and Alaska politicians in general.

  • vicky

    As a mother of five, my oldest 22, studying to be a doctor, my second 19, studying to be a doctor, my third 16 in eleventh grade, my forth 11, in sixth grade, and my youngest is 5, just started kinder garden. I have no time to do anything else but be a full time mother. I can’t imagine how anyone can be a mother of five, have a baby which also has a disability, and add an unmarried teenage pregnant daughter, can have the ability to run this country. Can you imagine the precedence she would give to running this country if the need arises? This women has to much on her plate already. She is not a good representative of working mothers as it seems she is not a good mother herself as she ignores her children as evidenced by her daughter becoming pregnant at 16 and this is only because the mother was not there to provide any guidance or moral support for her children. Teenage pregnancies nor morally happen in broken homes and morally inept people.

  • Lindata

    One of the patterns in Down’s Syndromw is hypotonia, that is low muscle tone, or “floppy baby” syndrome. From the pictures and the consistently quiet behavior, Trig seems to have it in spades. The problem is the baby’s lack of muscle tone makes the baby very passive and non-reactive which in turn leads to a lack of interaction with his or her environment including intrapersonal interaction with the caretakers which in turn leads to a lack of intellectual stimulation. Early intervention to strenghten the muscles, require social interaction, and provide that intellectual stimulation is vital for the baby to realize his or her full potential. This is not something you can do part time.

  • KansasKowboy

    I just hope the baby doesn’t hurt itself on that huge flag pin Sarah is wearing. (I know it has a ribbon on it too for her son that is in the military)

  • Commenter

    Don’t know if this has been touched upon, and I haven’t seen the other pictures in the set. But are there any other parents here who see something a little off about the way she’s holding the baby? She probably is just distracted by the cameras in her face, but to me the first thing that hit me about these pics is that she looks like someone holding a baby for the first time. A baby could wiggle out of those holds. Parents know this. (and I’m not suggesting it’s not her kid)

  • Progressive From Oregon

    “The initial rumor-mongering at Kos was not a “Kos piece” (a term which can only rightly be applied to the Front Page stories in the large left column), it was in a diary/blog written by a fairly new member of that community, which is open to the general public. Posted by: Julia Grey | Sep 01, 2008 at 01:24 PM”
    That the ’story’ of Palin possibly not being the mother of Trig started on Kos, or YouTube, is not true. By sheer coincidence, I sat down at my computer less than five minutes after the announcement of McCain’s VP. I had recently watched a 60 Minutes piece on Palin and had spent a couple of hours after 60 Minutes reading about her on the CBS website and a few connected pages. As I sat down at my computer after Palin being chosen, I decided to do a Google search on her. I was surprised at the volume and depth of newspaper articles on her at the websites of several Alaskan newspapers. Not thinking about possibly being at the apex of Palin information, I spent the next 3-4 hours reading about the questions surrounding her pregnancy, about the initail stages of ‘Troopergate’, (before it WAS Troopergate) and other stories.
    I have not seen ANY new information regarding Palin’s questioned pregnancy in print or electronic media that I didn’t read that morning. The entire story is there. The McCain campaign DIDN’T check the Alaskan newspapers when they did their lightweight vetting of Palin.
    I found out about a week after her selection that while I was reading about Palin, the person who made the first YouTube video was also reading the same articles I was. He began collecting clips and produced the YouTube post as I sat and continue to read.
    I guess I don’t have the instincts of a ’scoop’ reporter.

  • Wendy

    The crazies posting here and their crazy posts..is this the left? I would say..deranged is quite appropriate.