BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement

June 22, 2008

(Way) After The Flood

Bush-Water-Edge

(click for full size)

Short of re-donning a flight suit and posing looking back at the USS Abraham Lincoln, I couldn’t imagine another shot more evocative of Bush 43’s monumental failure.

This image, taken on Friday by Brooks Craft for the TIME White House photo blog, places GDub at the scene of yet another flood, this one in Iowa City.  What’s great about this pic — titled “Water’s Edge” — is how it captures Bush away from a whole gang of reporters, as if it was just him, us and this neighborhood underwater.

The “looking back” makes for a powerful metaphor, as if Bush is actually seeing a few things now that it’s mostly behind him.  At the same time, Craft captures Bush — accurately, I believe — as quite solitary and isolated, in spite of the staginess and all the people nearby.

(image: Brooks Kraft / Corbis for TIME.  June 21, 2008.  Iowa City)

  • http://www.jaxxattaxx.com/ black dog barking

    Hilarious! The Fortunate Son occupies the only tiny remaining bit of high ground. Painted himself into a corner as the nation under his watch fills up on disaster. Good luck to the next guy.
    Heckuva job Bushie!!

  • Neal

    The tide of history coming in. The drowning of the traditional suburban America happening on his watch. Separated from his roots. His feet are dry, but at what cost?
    Mission accomplished!!

  • http://someoldguy.wordpress.com/ Phil Sheehan

    Shirt sleeves rolled up, ready to tackle the job? I don’t think so.
    Hip toward the water, which puts head and shoulders away from it.
    Left hand rigid, right index finger poised.
    Most of all, the feet.
    Left foot apparently planted.
    But the right foot turned in and partially lifted.
    Fight or flight, and he’s not ready to fight.
    He’s posed and poised for a fast getaway.
    Eight years too late, for the rest of us.

  • http://www.agrippinaminor.com/wp/ Scarabus

    I have a copy of an early 19th century print showing the ghost of Napoleon contemplating his grave.
    This reminds me of Pete Seeger’s famous anti-war song “Waist Deep in the Big Muddy.” Here we have the ghost of stupid captain who led his platoon into the big muddy, looking back at the place he lost his life.
    (If you know the song, you’ll know what I mean. If you don’t know it, check it out. You’ll find it remarkably prescient.)

  • catfood

    He looks like an ordinary guy. I think that might lie at the heart of his extraordinary failure. Despite being born to wealth and privilege, he is in fact pretty average in intellect and ability. Nothing against average men and women but they are not qualified for the job of president.

  • Nemo

    A very ordinary man, out of his depth. The whole image sums up his presidency – staged to look heroic and all conquering – events have unfolded that neither he or his entourage are capable of controlling.
    Good luck to his successor who is bound to disappoint anyway.

  • mcc

    I like how the street appears (I think?) to be sloping downhill away from us, such that it looks like the houses further down the street are sinking down into the water, or the houses closer are climbing out. If we do interpret this as “looking back into the past” the implication seems to be that people finally now have their heads barely above the water but darned if things weren’t a lot worse not too long ago…

  • http://www.landsedgephoto.com Emily L. Ferguson

    Late to the party and without a clue of how to respond.
    (“OK. I looked at it. You mean I have to do something about it? Me? Why? It’s not my fault.”)
    Makes you wonder whether he knows how to pick up a shovel, and when. Maybe he only knows how to clear brush.
    This is what you get when you let God pick up all your responsibilities and forgive you for not doing anything about them yourself – a washed out, indifferent, bored, colorless nobody, looking for a way out.

  • Esoth

    His feet are dry, aren’t they, so what’s the problem? The body language, relaxed, not facing front to the water, reflects his core disinterest and uncaring, even as he fakes it. He’s going through the motions. Enough of Rove’s stagecrafting directions have sunk in that he gets right up to the edge of the water, but rather than do something dramatic, like stand in his Ecco’s right in the water, or crouch down, he just stands there, gazing, like, “Yep. Lot a water.” Not much confidence that guy is going to turn back the tide.

  • http://www.agrippinaminor.com/wp/ Scarabus

    Re Catfood’s comment, on my blog I once posted a photo of Bush at the top of the stairs of AF-1, looking very small relative to the position he was in. And on another occasion I posted a photo of him looking alone and very small behind a big stage and podium. My comment both times was that he’s a man too small for his job.
    Still, reasonably objective people who have done stories on Bush have said that, while he has zero intellectual curiosity, no interest in reading anything—especially if it’s likely to say something he doesn’t want to hear—he isn’t really as stupid as he sounds. (Yeah, I know. He couldn’t be!)
    Psychology is not my academic specialty, but I can’t help inferring that the real problem lies not with his intellect but with his personality. He seems a classically insecure bully, competing both with his father and with his brother, and extraordinarily subject to being manipulated through flattery.
    Dick Cheney is definitely smart, of course, and he knows how to make Bush dance by pulling his strings. That’s scary, because it means there’s every possibility the puppet will push the button that means bombing Iran.

  • http://profile.typekey.com/dquaranta@earthlink.net/ DennisQ

    Bush appears to be staring at a chartreuse-colored house at the water’s edge towards the left of the picture. Chartreuse is ordinarily a bright, cartoonish color used on packages of children’s fruity candy. But the house looks like the opposite of a smiley-face, the disapproving sad-face.
    The sad-face is reflected in the water amid the reflection of the trees and shadows on the water. The incongruity of the chartreuse among these ominous-looking shape makes the reflected sad-face look almost like a jack-o-lantern. There is a definite sense of menace in the picture, and Bush’s raised foot suggests his discomfort at the dark shapes in the water.
    Significantly, this is not a night time scene. If it were, the menace would be far more explicit. We associate supernatural threats with darkness because they are unseen. But the picture presents the menace of ordinary nature in daylight. The effect is unsettling.

  • quotheraven

    memore x lien

  • Puka

    “Now, watch this drive!”