BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Monday, May 21, 2012

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement



October 25, 2005

Bill Frist, Family Man

Fristfamilydogs

Fristfamily

In my last Frist post, I proposed to undertake an “informal inquiry” into the personality of Tennessee’s junior Senator.  Specifically, the BAG was hoping to use available photographs to sharpen the understanding of who Frist is, and how he operates.

In that previous entry, I presented a photo of Frist walking into his spanking new office on his first day as Senate Majority Leader.  Prominently displayed on the credenza was a framed black-and-white portrait of Frist himself, smiling, with fist on chin.

The discussion accompanying that post offered an impressive example of lay psychology, offering several possible diagnostic labels for Frist (narcissist; robot/schizoid; autistic; medical school-induced post traumatic stress syndrome) as well as a discussion of the ethics and viability of this kind of speculation.

(As I follow the photographic trail, I just hope the effort remains relevant — or even, sheds some understanding — as Frist becomes consumed with legal and ethical problems related to suspicious stock trading.)

Anyway, you’re probably wondering what’s with the dogs?

In assessing character, an obvious factor to look at is how a person regards his family.  In Frist’s case, he refers to them — his wife, Karyn, and his three teenage sons, Harrison, Jonathan and Bryan — as his “foundation in life.”

At last count, there were 47 separate albums in the photo section of Frist’s Senatorial website.  All told, these folders contain about 419 photos — if I counted right.  (… By the way, I’m guessing that this is a record for the number of on-line pictures of himself one Senator has offered to his constituents.)

In any case, one of these folders is dedicated to family.  That album, labeled  “Frist Family Photos” is 28th on the list, and contains two photos (or .48% of the total).  As shown above, the first image is dedicated to the family dogs.  The second shot — which is probably eight or nine years old by now — shows a run-of-the-mill snapshot of the immediate Frist clan taken from afar in what looks like a back yard.

For a man who has been through two Senate campaigns; has spent 11 years in the Senate; has attended who knows how many award ceremonies, dinners, prayer functions, commemorations, funerals; has spent most of the last year touting himself for POTUS; and apparently oversees even the most minute detail of his public presentation, I’m just wondering where is the photo documentation to support this man’s self-avowed Christian conservative family values?

I don’t know about you, but if I was part of the Frist family and this was my primary basis for evaluating the Senator’s compassion for his “foundation of life,” the dogs don’t come out half-bad.

(images: First Senatorial Website. Photo Gallery.)

  • Asta

    Frist doesn’t have any gray dogs, just black and white.
    (It’s too early in the morning for psychology, this is the best I can come up with.)

  • lemondloulou54

    While the dog looks white, it’s probably a yellow lab and an old one at that.
    The Frist family is framed by chain link. They are not a part of us. They’re behind a fence, safe and protected. It looks like Frist jumped in at the very last second for that shot because he sort of hunches in around one of the kids.
    He’s got a picture-perfect family. They’re all handsome and shiny, at least on the surface. Surface is what we’ll always get from them, alas.

  • Marysz

    Interestingly, the dog picture is the first one. The unconditional affection of the dogs is the only thing that holds the members of this family together. Are any of Frist’s sons in the military, serving in Iraq? They look the right age. Maybe they’re hiding from Michael Moore behind that fence. This family doesn’t want anyone getting too close who might find out the family secrets.

  • mugatea

    A friend of mine has noticed when he’s photographed he leans into the shot, like Frist is here. It drives my friend crazy because he’s been mildly trying to correct the behavior for years but shots keep coming up. Whatever the cause it looks like there’s a fear of not being included even though there is plenty of space in the frame.

  • Samizdata

    circle of life? pagan bastard… also looks cold-blooded… just wearing a dress shirt while the rest of the fam is in sweaters/ layered…
    o/t: saw rosa parks’ mug shot on billmon’s site… compare/contrast w/ delay’s?

  • http://www.denisdekat.com denisdekat

    Kat Killer a family man?

  • http://www.livejournal.com/users/vicfitz82 Victor F

    The picture of the dogs was taken from eye level. A more “compassionate” angle would involve squatting or kneeling on the ground to get a closer-to-dog-eye level picture. Getting close to one’s subject, especially if it is smaller, gives a photographer a more empathetic view. By just leaving the dogs on the ground where they belong, and towering over them with the camera, it looks to me like the photographer really doesn’t think the dogs are very important.
    Did Frist take those family photos himself? I don’t think my opinion of the photos would change if he did or did not make those pictures.
    People tend to lean into pictures if they are posing for a group photo. I see this all the time. People who don’t look through a camera every day don’t always know how the camera is going to see the picture. They assume you have to cram into a group photo because they think there won’t be enough space. From this post, though, I get the feeling Frist spends a lot of time in front of a camera and I’m sure he’s leaning in because he wants to be included, but does he really think the camera isn’t going to see him? Perhaps his egomania is causing him to lean, in this case, seeing as he even has a large picture of himself in his own office.
    I can understand if Frist doesn’t want to drag his family around while he’s chasing the political spotlight. Politics are ugly and any time you drag somebody you care about into the matter you’re opening that person up for attack. Maybe that’s why there are so few photos of his family on his website? But, if he touts his “family values,” why wouldn’t he put up more pictures of his family? Maybe, to him, they are just not impressive. Important, yes, but hardly worth more than a couple snapshots.

  • wire

    The group shot is dream imagery. The family posed too primly in the center of a tunnel or vortex or eye. The foliage is chaotic; unstructured; can’t be organized into a presentable form. It completely surrounds the family-unit. It has then at a distance, unavailable, masked, remote, constrained, enclosed. There is a lot in the way of the view, and the family is a shiny clean projection at the center of the vortex. Maybe some feelings there to be avoided. Guilt? The inclusion of the dogs from above amplifiy the neurotic aspects; the dogs are preent, near, available, subissive, adoring, also encroaching, invading, and in a visual context of closeness that is more harmonious with a family-oriented fantasy self. The dogs he can handle, but there’s turmoil about the family. I figure he knows about as much about his family as he does his dogs, and views them as equivilent. He knows this aint right, but he’s got plans and is so busy running the machine of himself.

  • http://www.woodka.com donna

    Where are the cat pictures?

  • Lt. Bighorn

    The first thing that struck me with the dogs is the black-and-white thing, too. Even if the “white” dog is really a yellow lab, the photo illustrates his black & white, good vs. evil Christian-conservative political philosophy. The long shadows also add to the mood of ominous darkness of Original Sin that the So-Cons imagine all around them. That picture could almost be an emblem of what that manichaean, pessimistic worldview.
    The family picture: I don’t read too much in the leaning, because Frist knew that the frame of the shot would be circular, and he might just have overcompensated for that. To me, the chain link fence represents Order, keeping the encroaching jungle of Chaos out. Again, the family is surrounded by life, energy, unpredictability, but they prefer the sterile confines of drab lifelessness.
    Except for Frist’s wife: She wears the sky on her torso, and her brown pants suggest earth, soil, even a hint of the scatological. The female principle of Gaia invades the wasteland.
    The hole in the fence is like a cannonball through the natural world. A blast of Order through the Chaos.

  • http://www.convergencetime.com/weaselden/ ice weasel

    There actually are other photos of a family nature there. You may have missed several under the header of “hunting”. Yes, the Frist man with a recently dead elk. I still think your point is well taken, for a “family man” and a fairly (forgive me) unhumble christian, not many family pics and not one at a church event.
    Whatever, it’s clearly contrived to image him in the way that some aid or intern that would be beneficial.
    Hell, I would never have included those marathon pictures in there. But that’s just me.

  • Asta

    I followed denisdekat’s link because I didn’t know about Frist’s following the footsteps of Victor Frankenstein in his earlier days. This passage caught my attention:
    “Frist disclosed that he went to animal shelters and pretended to adopt the cats, telling shelter personnel he intended to keep them as pets. Instead he used them to sharpen his surgical skills, killing them in the process.
    The article also implies that he used many cats. Which makes me wonder if it took a long time for Frist to hone his kills…I mean, skills.
    Frist has never struck me as the sharpest scapel on the surgical tray.
    (Maybe someone will clue me in as to why Ashcroft is so afraid of calico cats.)

  • http://profile.typekey.com/buda_jenn/ buda_jenn

    creapy

  • black dog barking

    Perhaps there are clues to Dr Frist’s attachment to his “foundation of life” in his 2003 book, the coyly titled
    Good People Beget Good People: A Geneology of the Frist Family
    .
    Dr Frist selected a photo of a house to grace the cover of the history of his family. House of Frist.
    BTW, neither the lawn beneath the dogs nor whatever is growing on the fence with the round hole look especially lush. Suggests infertility, blight.

  • Mad

    Frist is indeed weird.
    Imagine having a family portrait that is being promoted so as to glorify the man that wants to be the most powerful person in the universe. And in that family portrait the primary feature is a Fence. Second feature is the Hole in the Fence. And then the Family. But nobody in the family is touching any one else. No touchy-feely here in this Frosty Frist family. They each have little fence force-fields all around them. All kinds of weird.
    The dogs? From the bare earth, it looks like these dogs have a fence too. Maybe one of those invisible electronic fences- because they don’t seem to be able to get too close to the photographer. And the dogs are way down there. No touchy-feely here either.
    But, it may be that Frosty Frist is going to have a bigger problem with a fence- instead of the White House he may be headed for a stay in the Big House because of his ethics violations. One can only hope.

  • Mad

    Pardon the multiple posts, but either I am having problem on this end, or BagNotes has upset the Higher Powers with his Unpatriotic Attacks on a Great American President, and they are retaliating by disrupting the TypePad connection.

  • readytoblowagasket

    To Mad: I have been having technical difficulties since the site has been upgraded. Somehow today I found a back-door entrance, although I have no idea if this comment will post or if I’ll find the secret pathway back again after I post.

  • The BAG

    Sorry for the multiple posting problems. I think that the Typepad servers are often slow, so there might be a tendency to hit “Post” again before the request is recognized by the system and the comment is displayed. In any case, I will contact them about the situation.
    I think the analysis is really interesting here, by the way. Coldness, remoteness, barenness — I agree. (I’ve got more Frist coming (a bit of it that many of you have already been chewing on).

  • black dog barking

    There is a weak element of visual punning in the shot of Frist’s human family. The circular hole in the fence and its leafy outline anticipate a common matte for photographic portraits.
    Perhaps, then, this is a benchmark for analyzing the Frist wit, the threshold of funny for the Senate majority leader. Or maybe evidence the Senator is constantly probing his environment for photo opportunity.

  • Megan

    Frist’s wife is facing away from him, as are his kids. The kids are all centered on her, and he is at the periphery, looking in. Frist and his wife’s couplehood is not presented in this picture, much less at the center of the picture (or a loving family?).
    Their focus is not on each other in the family, but something ahead and to the right of the group.

  • readytoblowagasket

    I would expand on what Mad said about the first photo. Even animals have body language, and I think these dogs display wary obedience — their tails are lowered, not lifted in happy expectation of play; their paws are firmly planted on that barren patch of earth, the best position for running away to avoid a kick. The white older dog looks like he/she is about to bark in protest at the photographer, who must be Frist (or else why keep, let alone post, the photo?). The perspective of the shot is a perfect illustration of seeing through the all-powerful Top Dog’s eyes. There is no discernable evidence of loving human interaction with these dogs — not even a human shadow or the toe of a shoe poking into the frame. No dog toys, either. This is not the usual close-up shot of the spoiled and happy family pet you might see on a co-worker’s bulletin board; there’s something wrong, something disturbing about it.
    I think the second photo is set up with a timer, Frist being the photographer again, of course. He is the one who is in a different pose from the others, as if he set up the shot, then ran to take his position before the photo snapped. His body holds more tension than the others do (straight-backed as the rest of them are), and he has the goofy grin one gets from mastery of an instruction booklet. The family is contained in that tight little circle, their legs lopped off at the knees. We are not allowed to get any closer. It too is a photo about control.
    If Frist is the photographer in both (and why wouldn’t he be?), I think these photos tell as much or more about him as the photos OF him do. They are cold, emotionless images. I now see Frist as someone who can’t feel any emotions, any connection with others, but who knows he should try to fake it. Like the medical profession, “Christian conservative family values” is a great place to hide such a secret about oneself because it provides all the rules for you and comes with a built-in appearance of compassion.

  • http://www.lananfrank.net/lana/ amanuensis

    I can’t help but wonder … why the hell are they on THAT side of the fence? The camera gets the “ugly” side of the chain link fence, while the people are standing on the leafy side. It shows a complete lack of ANY cosideration for the picture itself, just the … tacky frame.
    Secondly, the circle is too low, it is centered on their waistlines rather than their faces. This could’ve been fixed by just bringing the tripod down. Again, the shot is “off” just because Frist can’t come down a level, similar to the dog shot.
    What it should look like: Biltmore Estate