BagNews Archives About Staff BagNews is a progressive site dedicated to visual politics and the analysis of news images.
Thursday, May 23, 2013

Twitter

@bagnewsnotes »
Advertisement

September 17, 2005

A Little Separation

Iraqbridge300

Overpasskid300

Time races, and then time slows down and you recollect.

On the morning of September 1st, I clearly remember the shocking headline at the top of the NYT website reporting a catastrophe on a bridge in Kadhimiya, outside Baghdad.  Almost 1,000 Shiite pilgrims had died in a stampede started by rumors of an imminent suicide bomb attack.  This awareness was a fleeting one, however, overshadowed by the overwhelming drive to absorb everything and anything about the expanding Katrina crisis.

The way the mind works, we are constantly processing separate types of information at the same time.  As a result, past events are usually recalled according to different kinds of experience, including emotions, thoughts, senses, and even physical postures we held at a particular moment.

Going back to the 1st, I can recall what I was thinking, where and how I was sitting, and what I was feeling at the point I was feverishly absorbing Katrina information, and then “cut over” to seek out available pictures from the Kadhimiya disaster.

Visually, I definitely recall the Imams Bridge — the spot where the pilgrims were trampled or jumped to their deaths.  At the same time, however, my head was so full of hurricane pictures, my visual memory is more a combination of elements defined by water, more water, bridges and highways.  In terms of thought, I remember that this Kadhimiya photo mixed just a little too easily with the scenes from the Gulf Coast.

There has been such a continuity to catastrophe lately, it has acquired an almost numbingly steady rhythm.  I know the misery in Iraq failed to pause for our hurricane.  I’m just hoping the Gulf Coast will regains a bit of normalcy soon so I can separate the two again.

(image 1: Jason Reed/Reuters. New Orleans. September 1, 2005. YahooNews.com.  image 2: Thaler Al Sudani/Reuters.  Kadhimiya  WAPO photo gallery. September 1, 2005.)

  • black dog barking

    I know the misery in Iraq failed to pause for our hurricane. I’m just hoping the Gulf Coast will regains a bit of normalcy soon so I can separate the two again.
    The parallel toll of civilian death caused by the breakdown of social order in Iraq is likely similar in number to the announced casualties from the Gulf Coast since Katrina made landfall. “Normalcy” has taken on distinctly different dimensions the past few years.

  • fotonique

    War zones and natural disasters have mingled before.
    You might also say that the misery in the Gulf Coast—although Katrina’s death toll thus far is less than 1000—has failed to pause for Iraq. Nature is a more formidable foe than terrorism.
    Perspective.

  • bg

    However, this may be the first time that disaster and war are joined at the hip by Haliburton.
    With this in common: lots of money spent, no results.

  • http://canadianlookingsouth.blogspot.com Cdn Looking South

    The memories you describe of the conflation of events on September 1 (also my birthday) is so significant to the experience of trauma as primarily a schism in time provoked by emotionally incomprehensible events and conditions. I was thinking the other day about the image of all of the sandals on the bridge in Iraq that day. Which made me think about the Iranian-American documentary filmmaker who was taken into custody by American and Iraqi military forces as he was researching an ancient bridge for a documentary. He was released late in August and speaking publicly just before September 1. And I was prompted to talk with my son about the shoes installation at the Holocaust Museum in DC and what about it makes it so evocative.

  • Mad

    Comments? Not many posted here.
    The photos don’t do much for me.
    That Bagman makes the connection between Iraq and Katrina is very important, however.
    Especially the water. Current wars and battles over oil will be as nothing compared to coming battles over water. Far too little water in many parts of the world, leading to slow death of people, societies and economies. And too much water in other parts of the world, leading to sudden catastrophes.
    Plus all of the other connections between Iraq and Katrina: poor planning, poor implementation, poor leadership. Poor people. Poor infrastructure. Inexcusable death and destruction. Not enough money to win. And Halliburton / corruption, as noted above. Much more.
    Bagman comments: “There has been such a continuity to catastrophe lately, it has acquired an almost numbingly steady rhythm.”
    Unfortunately, yes. To what extent is this related to the Bush Presidency and BushPlan?

  • Mad

    By the Way— notice that there is another tropical depression building. Expected to become a hurricane on Tuesday as it enters the Carribean.

  • Mad

    Pardon the brief geographically mental vacation- that tropical depression is expected to become a hurricane as it enters the Gulf of Mexico. And in the last hour it has become a tropical storm, named Rita.
    They should have called it Rove.