No other site reviews and critiques news images as well as publishes original photography — all in the name of helping you become a sharper “visual consumer.” Are you bombarded by powerful images from the world of news, culture and social media? Sign up for our “Week in Re-View” and let us help unpack them for you. Other sites read the words. We read the pictures.

Close
Archives About Staff BagNews is dedicated to visual politics, media literacy and the analysis of news images.
September 11, 2005

9/11 Wingnut Watch: Seeing Things

Flight93Memorialbig

In response to what otherwise seems like an eloquent proposal, certain wingnuts are literally getting bent out of shape over the design of a 9/11 memorial.

Recently unveiled to the public and to the families of those who died on Flight 93, this 2,000 acre memorial proposed for Pennsylvania has drawn widespread support and approval.  The problem the concrete-thinking right wingers are having, however, is the shape of the walkway.  Apparently, this path — lined with 40 separate rows of red and sugar maples (each row representing one of the 40 victims), and designed to follow the existing shape of the land — seems to remind the radicals too much of an Islamic crescent.

In highlighting the image, Michelle Malkin (who is fast becoming one of my favorite examples of what has gone terribly wrong with America) posted various choice comments by her fellow flat thinkers.  One asked: “What next–a holocaust memorial in the shape of a swastika?”

From a visual standpoint, it’s worth noting that these radicals are responding to a topographical model — an abstraction created to symbolically represent the project.  In reality, the memorial would hardly call out this impression (unless, perhaps, you were flying over it in an airplane at an unnaturally low altitude).  And still, the natural shades and shapes of the terrain, combined with the colors of the land, would likely never offer this kind of aerial contrast).

For those who see only bias, however, the impression of the “problem” might be better transmitted this way.  Below is a representation of the path shape from ground level.  Unless the design calls for carving the Islamic crescent into the trees, its hard to imagine there is much of an issue here.

Crescentground

(Story source: Making Light)

(Image: Paul Murdoch, architect.  Posted at 9/11 Memorial website)

Comments Powered by Disqus

Refresh Archives

Random Notes