Archives About Staff BagNews is dedicated to visual politics, media literacy and the analysis of news images.
October 20, 2004

The Kerry Album: NYTimes Returns To (De)Form

On Monday, the NYTimes offered respectful photo coverage of John Kerry. (They actually ran a JFK version of the “candidate in the adulating crowd” shot –which is almost a daily staple for Bush.)

The improvement, however, only lasted a day.

This (Tuesday) morning, the two candidates appeared on page A19 (with the Bush shot, once again, higher up the page). Because I love captions, and because I was trying to spare the harangue, I started thinking of titles — like “The Ego Has Landed” or “Divine Intervention.”

If the Times said they were just trying to be creative, I could almost buy that. But, what happened to the (at least somewhat) level playing field? Maybe their rationale had to do with an attempt at abstract impressionism. But, pairing the President with the American eagle (“Two Beaks Are Better Than One?”) is not nearly as weird as what they did with (or, you could say, to) Kerry.

nytbush10.19

nytkerry10.19

This shot of Kerry, far from pulling for recognizable (not to mention, respectful) themes, is just bizarre. And the negative connotations are hard to avoid. The one (obvious?) reading I make has John Q. Public reaching out to shake hands with Kerry, and the candidate — already maintaining a huge distance — shunning the offer. (And laughing about it!)

At the risk of redundancy, I have to say this shot not only reinforces the Kerry photo motifs I’ve been protesting recently, it express almost every one. Now, that’s impressive.

(My rating scorecard:)

kerryscorecard
  • alan palmer

    a pleasent change from the times, foto of a small billionaire (check forbes) wana be president.

  • Steve

    Perhaps the BAG protests too much.

    Actually, I think the Kerry shot is pretty good. It definitely catches the eye, which is pretty much the purpose of a photo of this sort.

    The shot of Bush, on the other hand, is pretty banal and uninteresting. The only thing at all interesting is the perhaps not-so-subtle inference that Bush leans to his right.

  • http://shlonkombakazay.blogspot.com liminal

    gReat job Norm! your analyses are perfect…lovin it.
    L.

  • http://blog.thought-mesh.net Annoying Old Guy

    Steve raises an interesting point. Perhaps the NY Times thinks it’s helping Kerry by being “artsy”, like the Guardian thinks it’s helping Kerry by having annoying British twits write to voters in Ohio.

  • http://pierrotsfolly.blogspot.com/ Harry

    Looks to me like God hisself is reaching down to grab a sinner. The evildoer will have the truth squeezed out of him and then be cast down into the depths of Hell!

Refresh Archives

Random Notes